Health Team

Study: HPV test detects cervical cancer

Posted April 6, 2009

A new landmark study shows testing for the human papillomavirus (HPV) is more effective than a PAP smear for detecting cervical cancer. The findings could change the way doctors around the world test for the disease.

Jodi McKinney says a HPV test helped her beat cervical cancer.

"When they first told me that I had cancer cells, I was devastated,” McKinney said.

The 43-year-old says while her routine PAP smear was negative, the HPV test was positive. The discovery allowed doctors to diagnose McKinney's cancer at an earlier stage.

Study: HPV test more effective than PAP smear Study: HPV test more effective than PAP smear

"I was able to avoid having the hysterectomy, the chemo, the radiation,” McKinney said.

The HPV virus causes nearly 90 percent of cervical cancers. A new study says that routine HPV testing for women over 30 could save millions of lives.

"The PAP smear is not as sensitive as the HPV," said general practitioner Dr. Steven Lamm. "There are a lot of women who might be negative on the PAP smear and then turn out to actually have cervical cancer."

In the United States, about 4,000 women die every year from cervical cancer. Worldwide, the disease kills more than 25 million women a year.

The study of 130,000 women was conducted in India, and partly funded by the maker of the HPV test. The National Cancer Institute says HPV testing should eventually replace pap smears.

"This will be the new standard,” Lamm said.

Gynecologists are being urged to make HPV testing part of a woman's annual exam along with the pap test.

"If your doctor doesn't offer it to you, please ask for it,” McKinney said. "Insist on it."

McKinney, who has five children, is now cancer-free. She said she is looking forward to watching her family grow.

It should be relatively simple for doctors to add the HPV test to the annual gynecological exam – it uses the same tissue sample taken during the PAP test, and does not require any additional discomfort for the patient.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • CherryDarling Apr 7, 2009

    Maddie - insist your doctor do it, whether your Pap comes back okay or not. Like the article says, it can be done during your Pap with NO PROBLEM. I have the BEST doctor in the world, who has always tested me for both - regardless. I am in the middle of waiting for biopsy results from his office, which is the end result of my HPV results.

    If your drs office gives you pushback or grief about it, it's time to find another doctor.

    This could save your life.

  • Maddie girl Apr 7, 2009

    I just called my Doctors office and ask about it, they said they do it if pap smear comes back abnormal. I'm confused, maybe insurance doesn't pay unless they have a reason to do the HPV test ???