Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

4:44 a.m. • 5-24-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 72° F
  • Sat: Clear.
    • Hi: 72° F
  • Sun: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 75° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image
Go Ask Mom
print friendly

Study finds children of working moms face more health problems

Published: 2011-02-18 09:04:42
Updated: 2011-02-18 09:04:42

There's a new study that I suspect will spark another skirmish in the ongoing "mommy wars." And it comes from right here in the Triangle.

According to new research from N.C. State University, children of working moms are significantly more likely to experience health problems, including asthma and accidents than children with moms who don't work.

“I don’t think anyone should make sweeping value judgments based on a mother’s decision to work or not work,” says Dr. Melinda Morrill, research assistant professor of economics in the Poole College’s Department of Economics and author of the study. “But, it is important that we are aware of the costs and benefits associated with a mother’s decision to work.”

She said that in a press release, which I'm borrowing heavily from here.

The study looked at the health of school-age children who have at least one younger sibling. When a mother works, the study found, it leads to a 200 percent increase in the child’s risk of having each of three different adverse health events: overnight hospitalizations, asthma episodes, and injuries or poisonings.

Earlier studies have shown that, on average, children have better health outcomes when the mother works because of increased income, availability of health insurance and an increase in the mother's self-esteem.

Morrill found that wasn't the case. Morrill focused on the causal relationship between mothers working and children’s health. Morrill’s approach accounts for a number of confounding factors, such as how a child’s health affects the mother’s ability to work. For example, if a child is very sick, the mother may be more likely to stay at home.

“I wanted to look at mothers whose decision to work was not based on their children’s health,” Morrill said in the press release, explaining that a woman’s youngest child’s eligibility for kindergarten can influence her ability to return to the workforce. In assessing health outcomes, Morrill looked only at older children already enrolled in school, between the ages of 7 and 17, whose youngest sibling was around kindergarten age.

The study examined 20 years worth of data covering approximately 89,000 children from the CDC’s National Health Interview Survey. The data were collected between 1985 and 2004.


Read More Posts from this Blog

21 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.


page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Any thoughts that these children of working mothers are more likely to be in daycare/afterschool care or under the care of other people? That alone increases hospitalizations, illnesses, poisonings, and accidents. What about those whose mothers work but Daddy stays home?

I do not agree at all with this finding. I think kids of moms that are freaky about germs are more likely to sick than any other moms working or non-working. I think most people would agree. I know my friends that are so concerned about germs there kids get sick more than any other kids that I know of and they have asthma, and a lot other major illnesses as well.

I agree with murdock that to assume that a mother working (fathers have nothing to do with this equation?) is the cause of increased health problems is oversimplified. That correlation may exist, but unless we identify WHY, the study has little value. Are school age children more stressed and therefore more likely to get sick? Are they more predominantly from poorer families lacking quality health care? Do these children more often live in housing that contributes to asthma? Do babysitters or afterschool programs for school age children need better hygiene education or tougher licensing standards? This article seriously needs more information.

The study should look at what the children's diet consists of. Most working mothers feed their infants formula. It is a proven fact that breastfeeding or providing pumped breast milk will prevent many illnesses and diseases. As the child grows, maintaining a healthy, balanced diet that consists of something more than happy meals is sure to help them stay healthy.

kimmyb - To assume that working mothers only use formula and then feed older children nothing but happy meals is beyond ignorant. I am a working mother of 3 and breastfed all my children, and they do not eat fast food any more often than children of stay at home moms. The point is, kids get sick. Period. Whether you work or stay home, you do what is best for your family and as long as your kids are your top priority, they will turn out fine. Moms need to quit arguing over who's better and just focus on doing what's right for them.

@carolinagirl28 Amen, sister!

The is a bunch of mess... I am a single mother by my husband that died suddenly when my child was a little girl.. She is healthy and very happy and I am a full time employee.. I have taught her how to not share drinks, lip gloss or food (double dipping with sauces)etc.. and to always be clean to prevent sickness. My child has always been 1st in my life and she will always be... Most children want their mothers home with them when they are sick anyway.. I love my job and they are great with family emergency but if they didn't understand I would tell them goodbye... My child doesn't eat fast food and she comes home with me and I cook for us and I also get up every morning and cook her a nice breakfast!! I am no different than any other working mom and a non working mom!!! So far she has made it 12 years and counting with the way we live and no complaints from either one of us.. The key to keeping kids from getting sick all the time is being a good housekeeper and teach the children to wa

I have two boys, ages 6 and 9. I have worked full time since they were babies. My 9 year old has never missed a day of school due to an illness...he's never missed a day of school for anything for that matter. My six year old has missed 1 day of school for an upset stomach. Otherwise, by the grace of God, they have no health problems. And I breastfed my kids for over 6 months WHILE WORKING. So I really don't give this article any credence whatsoever.

I would actually like to see the tests of significance they used in this study in their sampling methods. Other than what Murdock offered, that kids of working moms tend to be in daycare/childcare and that will naturally lend itself to germ-sharing, I can't see where the mom deciding to work is going to directly affect her kid's health.

It all depends on the quality of the child's environment, whether it is in the home or at a child care center.

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Video

 
  • The students and staff at Cedar Fork Elementary star in a music video to capture their journey of learning for this year. The lyrics…

  • Leeann Eagle talks about her business creating personalized and appliqued apparel for kids.

  • Check out the scene at our big playdate featuring Artspace, Lil' Chef, the Chick-fil-A cow, Rissi Palmer, the Wake County Sheriff's…

  • Cristin DeRonja, director of the SAFEchild Advocacy Center and a Raleigh mom of four, tells us that listening to your children is…

  • LeeAnn Donnelly of Biltmore talks about the estate in Asheville and spots that families shouldn't miss when the visit.

  • Anna Norton, a Cary mom, talks about her journey with Type 1 diabetes, her involvement in Diabetes Sisters and the nonprofit's…

  • The city celebrates the grand reopening of its historic carousel on Saturday, April 20.

  • Julie Stoner, a Raleigh mom of two, will compete in her first Boston Marathon on Monday.

  • Go Ask Mom editor Sarah Lindenfield Hall talks with WRAL about preparing for a half marathon and how running can help moms stay…

  • Cristin DeRonja of SAFEchild in Wake County talks about the agency's program called Funny Tummy Feelings, which teaches kids skills…

  • Mary Poole, Artspace executive director, talks about the collection of artist studios and galleries in downtown Raleigh and why it's…

  • Beatrice Diaz, a mom of four in Chapel Hill, talks about her business Absolute Joy.

  • The best part about the playground at north Raleigh's Optimist Park is it's in the shade. And when the kids get too hot, you can just…

  • Cristin DeRonja, director of the SAFEchild Advocacy Center, talks about the programs offered at the Wake County nonprofit.

  • Cristin DeRonja, director of the SAFEchild Advocacy Center in Raleigh, talks about the four kinds of child abuse and what you can do…

  • Robyn Bennai and Liz Lemons, Raleigh moms, talk about their venture - shopbidgive.com - which provides an online home for silent…

  • Buffaloe Road Athletic Park, home to the Buffaloe Road Aquatics Center, also features a small playground.

  • Rosalind Baglio, manager of the Chapel Hill boutique, talks about what the store offers. It's part of the Women's Birth & Wellness…


GoAskMom Camp Guide promo 320x110