Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

5:25 a.m. • 5-24-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 72° F
  • Sat: Clear.
    • Hi: 72° F
  • Sun: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 75° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image

WRAL Adoption Blog

Michelle Donahue Hillison, an adoptive parent and licensed foster parent, shares about her family's adoption experiences and takes a look at adoption today. 

RSS Feed
My friend Jenna with her two lovely children
print friendly

My friend on Dr. Phil

Published: 2007-01-09 19:41:00
Updated: 2007-01-10 01:16:48

My dear friend Jenna, who writes the blog Family Living, Hatfield Style is going to be on Dr. Phil soon talking about unethical adoption issues. She is a birthmother with an open adoption with a great family, who I've gotten to know some as well online. Jenna is frequent commenter here as well as our personal private blogs. She has been a sounding board for me in opening up our adoption. Whenever I need an alternate perspective, she gives it to me unvarnished. She is the first birthmother I knew enough to ask blunt questions. Her pain and honesty have made me consider things I really wasn't prepared to deal with in my mind.

Adoption is such a hot button issue these days - think of the cases we've had just here in the Triangle with the Needham twins abduction to Canada, the death of the adopted little boy from foster care and the death of the adopted Russian child. These cases have made people think about adoption.

In the past, the perception of birth parents was often wrong. Much of America had such a lousy opinion of birth mothers; it is getting better but people like Jenna are going really help people see birth parents in a new light. Some people harbor fantasies about birth mothers - they either want to beleive that they are a smart lovely 16 year old who make a single mistake with her nice boyfriend, or they think they are cruel, heartless and drug addicted women. Jenna is neither of those but is closer to the former as she is a wonderful woman living now a happy life. After placing her daughter, she finished college, got a good job, got married and had another child. She's a charming and smart woman who stays in touch with her daughter and adopted family. She is present in her daughter's life.

Some of the people who are against adoption rave on and on, generalizing problems in the industry as more rampant than they are. Thank goodness we don't live in a time with the true evil adoption agencies of the past that stole, coerced and did whatever they wanted with no records. However there are still cases where the agencies involved haven't handled things in a way that protects everyone's needs. And that is what Jenna is going to talk about on Dr. Phil. She is going to wow everyone and it will help really educate the general public.

I support open adoption discussions becase adoption is not perfect. Changes need to be made to several parts of the process and options made available. A woman should never be coerced into adoption. Women should have counseling offered to them, time to make decisions and access to the resources to make that happen.

However I still think adoption is good and I have faith in people that adoption can be reformed and emerge in a form to protect  threchild, birthmothers and adoptive parents alike. My adoption was ethical and I'm comfortable with how it was all handled. Everyone should have that feeling - all three members of the triad.


Read More Posts from this Blog

4 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.


page 1
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Too much emphasis is placed on the rights of the adoptive parents and the birthparents. What about the adoptee (and please don't refer to us as children - we do grow up to be adults, you know). We are excluded entirely from the process and told to "be grateful for what you have" or, if our experience was bad, shrugged off as "well, your experience wasn't good and that's why you feel that way." False. Adoptees may have questions that simply can't be answered or a need to know our roots. Some don't have this; those of us who do should not be treated as abnormal and dismissed.

Thank you. My adoption was also ethical. It was the birthmother's decision for it to be a closed adoption. There are open adoptions at my agency where they actually do see the birthmother. One of them placed a 2nd child w/ the adoptive parents; they were contacted by her to place the baby. Thank you for continuing to show the positive side. Not all of anything is good or bad. Not all parents that keep their children take care of them either. Adoption can be a wonderful thing for all parties if it is handled correctly. I do know that more regulation (ex. - making adoptive parents uphold their open agreements) would be beneficial.

The problem is that open adoptions are not enforceable by law. Nothing obligates adoptives from continuing access once the adoptions are final. Many promise contact but cut it off once they've got those papers signed. My adoption was supposed to be open. Instead, they cut contact and I was told lies (which is how I discovered the truth -realized I wasn't told the same story twice). All but 5 states seal records and searching is not as easy as portrayed in the media. We who successfully search are the rare and lucky few. It is NOT "that easy" and NO "everyone can do it if they want to, especially with the internet today" is not true.

My adoption was ethical and I'm comfortable with how it was all handled. Everyone should have that feeling - all three members of the triad.

That's a great, OUTSTANDING statement, Michelle. Such a great point! I think I may have to store that away in some corner of my brain reserved for adoption issues so I can bust it out when necessary.

Thank you for your continued support. :)

page 1
sort order: oldest first | newest first