Local News

Juvenile murder arrests frightening, Wake DA says

Posted January 24, 2013
Updated January 25, 2013

— Over the past six months, Wake County authorities have arrested seven boys under age 16 in four homicides – a statistic Wake County District Attorney Colon Willoughby describes as troubling.

"It's very frightening," Willoughby said Thursday. "It's frightening to me, it's frightening to law enforcement, and it's probably frightening to the community."

The latest arrests happened Wednesday when Wake County sheriff's investigators arrested two teens, one 15, on first-degree murder in the case of Jose and Maria Mendoza, who were found shot to death in their home near Garner on Jan. 5.

Last month, four teens, one 13 and three 15, were arrested for allegedly beating Regynald Jose Brown to death with a rock. His body was found by friends on a trail of Raleigh's Capital Area Greenway.

Two teen brothers were also arrested in August for the death of 16-year-old Fernando Garibay-Benitez, who was on his way home from the store when, authorities say, a 13-year-old in a van, driven by a 15-year-old, shot him.

"We're talking about random violence, violence with firearms, people being murdered in their own home," Willoughby said. "That should be scary to every citizen who lives in Wake County."

In each of the crimes, authorities have either determined them to be gang-related or are looking into the possibility.

Willoughby believes gangs are only part of the problem. He says major cuts in recent years to the state's juvenile justice resources are another concern.

Wake County District Attorney Colon Willoughby Juvenile murder arrests frightening, Wake DA says

"We've closed juvenile training schools. We have long waits for out-of-home placement for juveniles, and there is a movement, on behalf of some, to expand the juvenile age up to 18, which I think would be a disaster," he said.

The "Raise the Age" effort, which has gained the approval of a House legislative committee would apply only to misdemeanors by offenders who are under 18. Those who commit a felony would remain in the adult justice system.

State officials, however, say the recent Wake cases don't reflect statewide crime numbers involving juveniles.

"They're horrible events, but they're not the norm," said Robin Jenkins, deputy director of the North Carolina Division of Juvenile Justice. "The data doesn't suggest that youth gang problems or youth violence is on the rise."

In fact, he says, the data suggests the opposite.

From 2008 to 2012, the number of juveniles in North Carolina who committed violent crimes dropped 22 percent, according to numbers from the North Carolina Department of Public Safety.

Wake County mirrors that downward trend. Violent crime among juveniles dropped from 8.3 percent in 2008 to 4. 2 percent last year.

Regardless of the statistics, Willoughby says that even one murder involving a juvenile suspect is one is too many.

The brothers charged in Garibay-Benitez's death, Brayan Hernandez-Sierra, 13, and Ceferino Hernandez-Sierra, 15, were indicted last month as adults on charges of first-degree murder.

Prosecutors have asked the court for the suspects in Brown's case to be tried as adults – a probable cause hearing is scheduled for Feb. 27 – and they haven't indicated whether they will in the Mendozas' deaths.

Willoughby says that generally in a first-degree murder case, it is appropriate to try teens as adults.

"Those are very serious crimes, and it would be a rare circumstance in which we would not seek to have someone in adult court for that kind of crime," he said.

40 Comments

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Oldest First
View all
  • pipcolt Jan 25, 7:50 p.m.

    If they are members of gangs then ship them off to where we house the terrorist, because that is exactly what they are.

  • miseem Jan 25, 7:39 p.m.

    Sounds like time to change the penalty for juvenile crimes. Anything involving a weapon for anyone over 12 should require prison/incarceration terms beyond age 18. Don't think a 14 year old won't shoot you? How much are you willing to bet one it?

  • newtonatlaw1 Jan 25, 6:54 p.m.

    JohnDresher: You make a sound point while challenging sacred cows some use to institutionalize failure of personal responsibility. I hope someone takes note and you are able to advise on public safety from your observance of our community and perspective as a writer chronicling this trend. I appreciate your input. Deb, Attorney

  • SARCASTICLES Jan 25, 4:51 p.m.

    Mr. Drescher, I wasn't "calling" you a conservative, but simply asking you if you were one, based on your opinion.

    I agree with you about the cultural tendency toward this type of shocking, cold-blooded violence.

    In spite of your hyperbolic attack on me personally, I'll assume that you don't usually put labels on people and categorize them into various identity groups such as "Progressive Liberal", which I certainly ain't.

    I was making an attempt to illustrate that, even though we don't necessarily agree politically, we can find some common ground on common sense issues such as this one, and agree that it is indeed a serious problem which all of us should work together to solve. Deal?

  • Terkel Jan 25, 3:29 p.m.

    beachmama, you confuse spanking with hitting.

  • That Explains It Jan 25, 3:26 p.m.

    Wow, Lady Justice, I guess, to you, simply attacking me personally is adding "something." No problem.

  • Lady Justice Jan 25, 3:08 p.m.

    "rich son, mass murder is such a very minute part of the overall murder rate that I'm not sure you can draw that conclusion."

    JohnDrescher

    That is not even close to an answer to the question asked. Looks like you really have nothing of substance to bring to the table. You talk, talk, talk about groups of people, but have nothing to offer when asked to provide some real insight into the why's and what can be done to repair the problem. Just all talk with nothing productive to add.

  • That Explains It Jan 25, 2:21 p.m.

    Sarcasticles, riddle me this. People who try to put labels on people and categorize them into various identity groups rather than deal with people as individuals are typically Progressive Liberals.

  • SARCASTICLES Jan 25, 2:01 p.m.

    Mr. Drescher, would you identify yourself as a conservative?

  • dollibug Jan 25, 1:58 p.m.

    What is more frightening to me is when the GRAND JURY can indict people without any EVIDENCE.....it is one thing to have *something*....but not when there is *NOTHING*....

More...