GOLO: Go Local. Talk Local. Share Local.
amvaugha is still immaculate: blog ↓

beautiful life


sen. david vitter confronted by local rape victim

Published Nov. 3, 2009
Views: 1108

Excerpts By Patricia Murphy

Sen. David Vitter (R-La.) had a heated exchange with a constituent over the weekend when she asked him why he opposed a bill that will protect the rights of some rape victims to take their attackers to court.

The bill stems from a 2007 case in which a Halliburton employee accused several co-workers of raping her when she was working for the company in Iraq. Her employment contract specifically required her to settle her complaint in arbitration rather than in criminal court. Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) sponsored an amendment to the defense spending bill to block federal funding from government contractors with similar employment contracts. Vitter joined 29 Republicans in opposing the measure, which passed the Senate 68 to 30 in October. Republicans at the time said it would give Congress too much influence over Pentagon contracts.

At the weekend event, a woman, who has not been named in the media, approached Vitter after a health care town hall event that the senator sponsored in Baton Rouge. A video of the encounter shows her speaking to the senator as he is leaving, saying, "Senator, I am a rape victim."

Vitter stops briefly to speak with her, but the two begin to speak over each other once the discussion turns to the Franken amendment.

Eventually Vitter says, "You realize President Obama was against that amendment and his administration was against that amendment?"

She responds, "But I'm not asking Obama. I'm asking you."

"Do you think he's in favor in rape?" Vitter asks rhetorically. "No." He then walks away and leaves the building.

As he walks away, the woman calls out, "What if it was your daughter?" 

Sen. Vitter's office did not respond to requests for comment on the event, but the senator did speak with a local television station at the town hall, which he said was organized so that he could hear from his constituents about their concerns. "I think people's biggest frustration is that they think they're being shut out of the debate and they just aren't heard in Washington," Vitter told WBRZ-TV.

You should be able to see the exchange here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6YZ1wP1978&feature=player_embedded

Filed under: News & Issues




70 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.

View Comments View Comments


page 1 | 2 | 3
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Arbitration should only cover business laws not being broken, not actual criminal laws which would therefore make it legal for one employee to rape another and get away with it.

That's a travesty, and anyone who can't see it is either a moron or is in someone else's pockets.

In my opinion, Halliburton should be sued by the woman for sheltering these animals, Arbitration Contract be d4mned.

And furthermore, Halliburton is treading a very dangerous rope doing this. If they don't mend this now, soon they'll be finding themselves with larger crimes to arbitrate, like murder.

God bless.

RB

Washington ain't listening because ignorant voters keep voting!!! (witness the last presidential election)...so why should they listen..????

Actually its the last 3 elections. Thats one nasty contract. If you get murdered, do you have to settle through arbitration also?

Strange that a crime of rape would be settled in arbitration.

This is not about a wage or job task issue, it is an assault issue.

Washington ain't listening because ignorant voters keep voting!!! (witness the last presidential election)...so why should they listen..????

...........

This is the root cause. Until we have term limit, WE, PEOPLE have to keep on voting out incumbents !!!

So let me ask this question.....on the contract it asks whether a person has been convicted of a felony these men can actually say no because there has never been a conciction? Wow,this truly amazes me in todays society. And to suggest a woman to avoid signing away her rights to NOT be raped is a solution in this matter? Come on guys, you are going about this the wrong way. Ask yourself, "Who would you support? The rapist or the victim?" NOTHING gives a man the right to rape any woman!

I would be curious to know exactly what the employment contract says. If I read that I had to take "complaints" against my employer or fellow employees to arbitration rather than civil court I would not for a second think that would apply to charges that someone committed a violent crime against me. I can't imagine any reasonable person who would interpret it that way.

Does anyone know the actual language of the employment contract, or are we just speculating here?

As far as I know, employment contracts are not sacrosanct. Courts can, and I believe have, deemed some provisions to be unenforceable in the past. If I were a politician, I don't think I would want to defend an employer's "right" to prevent an employee from facing her rapist in court.

You can wrap it in all the legalese in the world, but it will still stink.

Requiring someone to sign a contract for employment that requires someone to not bring a criminal complaint against a co-worker if that co-worker commits a crime against you, should not be legal.

And yes... the ignorant voters that elected all those Republican presidents in the last 50 years keep voting.

Washington ain't listening because ignorant voters keep voting!!! (witness the last presidential election)...so why should they listen..????

What is sad is the number of dolts that immediately conclude the amendment should have any merits. And for some because it was not supported by Republicans, they surely did not support it for terrible reasons. How about this? You take a job that requires you to sign a contract. IF the terms of the contract are not suitable to you, then DO NOT TAKE THE JOB. This is called taking responsibility for your DECISIONs. I have a question for some of you. Would you sign a contract that stipulated you could not bring criminal complaint against a coworker or an employer? If yes, and a crime happens to you, then you live by the terms of the contract you signed.

LMAO @ dooshbaggery

page 1 | 2 | 3
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Please log in to add comment.

most recent
   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

shared & sharing at thanksgiving

Hope all your meals have gone well. We're holding off the turkey until this afternoon. We're sharing...

not your mama`s dressing

2 cups bread crumbs 1 cup chopped...

what's wrong with this picture?

After a year and a month, 5,000 resumes,700 online applications, networking until your blue in the face. What's wrong with that picture? Companies are still not hiring.

thanksgiving with a twist

This year my family and I have found ourselves with no where to go for thanksgiving day. My mother...

how about a 'corny' thanksgiving?

           An Old Tradition For Modern...

thanks, god and ben franklin!

  I am thankful that I do not live in the “good old days”. When I hear...

missing children's group: thursday thanksgiving blog

  EVEN DURING THE HOLIDAYS, ESPECIALLY DURING THE HOLIDAYS, WE SHOULD REMEMBER....................................       ...

thanksgiving in afghanistan........(a repost)

Thank you seems so inadequate, but, what else can you say on this our national day of thanks. ...

wishing everyone a happy thanksgiving!!!

With Family coming in at anytime now I wanted to take a few minutes to wish you All a very Happy Thanksgiving!!!   I...

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

Generic Profile Image

profile of progrills

It aint over till its over...........

Generic Profile Image

profile of barbedwards1982

I'm the mother of two wonderful children, a son age 10 and a daughter age 7. I have been married to...

profile of the m group interiors

Interior Designers serving clients in Raleigh, Durham, Chapel Hill, Cary, Wake Forest and surrounding counties.

profile of tafiliclan1

Where you're going dictates your past.

profile of cokacolasis

fry the child killers and rapist, do not let them lay up in prison for years and years, while we the taxpayers pay for the room and board. take my money and crank up sparky!

Generic Profile Image

profile of rangerdavid

Gun totin left wing liberal vegitarian

profile of faye prosser - smart shopper

My goal is to help everyone live more comfortably within their means. I love to spread the...

Generic Profile Image

profile of js_2

Too busy.

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

privately public (7 members)

A Public Group for Blogging for "Friends Only" profiles.   This group...

golo happy birthday club (26 members)

  1/8 - justafella  2/2 - sandlapper 2/9 - Sue Donym  2/10-Pom...

therustybucketkidsclub (3 members)

Fans of The Rusty Bucket Kids Club, as well as cast and crew share the fun and the joy the movie and music are bringing to the community.

the book club (17 members)

This group is for those that would like to get involved with monthly readings, or readings at your...

Generic Profile Image

veterans affairs-are you a vfw (2 members)

OK, lets hear from all our proud Veterans here in Golo land! What branch of service were/are...

unemployed goloers corporation (10 members)

The unemployed Goloers Corporation is a newly formed corporation that contains the skills of all people...

motivation for weight loss (4 members)

If you want to lose weight or have already lost the weight.. we need each other to inspire each other to reach the determined goal..

golo weight loss buddy group (9 members)

  This group is for anyone (male or female) interested in "buddying up" with...

crew the raccoon (1 member)

Fans, volunteers and freinds of the Peak City Film Festival in historic downtown Apex, NC, November 20, 21, 22  2009.  

Generic Profile Image

the throne of wisdom (12 members)

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of 007 - granco.shhhhh dont tell

For all the nonbelievers in Golo-land:   ...

profile of godschild43

I believe that God is the way the truth and light. Always live by him.

afraid to kill

Here is another column by retired Colonel Ralph Peters, by far my favorite columnist, he writes for...

my holidays suck, so yours can be great!

Not to be a downer, BUT, it's another thanksgiving, and here I sit, as with most holidays, surrounded...

tear-eyed newscast this morning

 Photo changed to scene titled "Gateway to Heaven" in honor of the mother and...

thankful to lead a dog's life

Saw this story last night and I thought it couldn't help but to bring a grin to anyone's...

thanks, god and ben franklin!

  I am thankful that I do not live in the “good old days”. When I hear...

the worst thanksgiving ever

  It was my first Thanksgiving as a single mother.  I had no family in Minnesota...

anyone up for a barney thanksgiving?

 "I love you, you love me" "Please don't confuse me with the turkey."       :-))