Golo
sandra carrington-smith: blog

sandracarringtonsmith's blog


criticism: friend or foe?

Published Oct. 12, 2008

Criticism is often perceived as a personal attack, and our first reaction, when others criticize our actions or thoughts, is to become defensive and, often, lash back.

 

When someone criticizes our behavior or words, we feel undermined, and are afraid that once discredited, our personal worth is compromised in the eyes of the world.

 

As children, our greatest goal is to please adults and hear their words of praise. As adults, things don’t change much. We long to be connected to others, and become distraught when we feel rejected.

 

No matter what the issue at hand, people will have different opinions. Although some will choose to spew their position using less than desirable words, it is possible that a bit of truth is hidden within the wave of negative statements.

 

Many of us argue with others merely to hear a confirmation of our own beliefs; receiving approval for what we think or feel gives us a sense of validity of our own ideas, and reinforces our resolve to believe in them.

 

When we are entirely comfortable with something, we don’t feel the need to argue our point, as we know that, no matter how others feel, our ideas are unchangeable, and we will stick by them even if we are one against the rest of the world. When we argue – and especially when we become belligerent around the issue we are arguing about – is simply because we are still trying to figure out the validity of what we are stating. We seek approval from others in supporting us against those who don’t agree with us, as we feel comforted by the power of numbers. If others agree, we assume, our ideas must be right.

 

How can we accept criticism as our friend, and turn a negative into a positive?

 

1)      Take time to cool off, so that raw emotions won’t cloud your judgment. Delay response until able to process the meaning of what’s being said.

2)      Turn a negative into a positive. Rather than arguing your point, seek the silver lining within the hurtful words. Everything has a positive side.

3)      Be open minded enough to accept the fact that there may be some truth in the hurtful words, and commit to try to see if you can indeed learn something new.

4)      Criticism is very rarely a personal attack. It may be an attack of your words or actions, but it is not inherently directed to you as a person. Learn how to detach the two.

5)      Remain calm and positive, and take the opportunity to clarify your views without feeling you have to become defensive. You are not being personally attacked. Thank the other party for their opinion. After all, opinion is tied to individual perception and does not always reflect reality.

 

 Ultimately, criticism can be a positive thing, if it is viewed as such. And we’ll feel good knowing we have turned an enemy into a long lasting friend.

 



39 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.



page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

The way we perceive criticism is everything. If we recognize it as the constructive variety and can learn from it without harboring resentment, it can be a very positive thing.

On the flip side, even constructive criticism loses any potential benefit it it's perceived purely as a personal attack. Common sense, I guess.

That's a very good point, IfByWhiskey. A lot of people who harshly criticize others are truly criticizing themselves in an indirect way.

Yup. Not only that, but some people do not take criticism well. What's common in those people is that they are often a harsh 'self-critic'. Like myself. ;)

IfByWhiskey, the way you deliver your opinion will make a difference whether people will be receptive to your point or not. When people get so bent out of shape arguing their point makes me wonder the validity of their point.

I don't mind someone being blunt with me. In fact, I prefer it. But not cruel. Depending on the situation, I may be blunt or I may temper the statement to salvage feelings.

My sister and I both use the comment, "It's all in the delivery!" Two people can say the exact same thing, but from one it will be accepted as constructive statement and from another it's criticism. And the difference is always in the delivery!

Yeah, but how about 'it's not what you say but how you say it' part? Kind of germain to your original post ain't it?

There is a place for constructive criticism. We could all use a little of it, I would imagine.

Seems to me, though...... that most, or at least half the people in the world are totally inept in their delivery of it. And therein, lies the rub, most of the time.

I firmly support the "Live and let live" statement, IfByWhiskey.

'Criticism' has a negative connotation, but it should not, because you have just used critical thinking to come to your conclusion. OTOH, HOW you voice your criticism really means a lot in the totality of it. Like the old saying says, it's not what you say but how you say it. There is also a lot to be said about 'live and let live', and not be a 'buttinski'.

Me too!

typooos ar NO biggggie...lol

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Please log in to add comment.

most recent
   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

teen pregnancy

Mississippi now has the nation's highest teen pregnancy rate, displacing Texas and New Mexico for...

for all of my single moms...

Her Will by Sally  Lonely words on doorstep the day he walked...

is this what she meant ?

Opened MySpace this morning to check on the messages, updates, etcetera...And lo & behold, here is...

whatever!!!

Why is it, that no matter the topic or situation some people always seem to find a way to add how...

bail out!

Ok, it was the Banks, then the Auto makers, now, check this out, Porn wants their Bail out share. ...

day 13

I will quit boring everyone with this view, plus we are supposed to start warming up some this weekend,...

rx drug costs too much?

I found these resources this morning & decided to post them all in one place, in case there are...

so it's my birthday

Alright I shared this wtih a few friends yesterday, but today is my 30th birthday and I'm happy because...

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of ethelhayworth

Ethel Hayworth has been teaching resume writing and creative...

profile of isabelamontesa

Born December 25, 1975. A Capricorn. The youngest of three children. Neither smoke nor drink alcoholic...

profile of melissahayden

More than anything, Melissa Hayden, gives priority to her research...

profile of alohawoods

I'm a north carolina girl at heart and I'm hoping WRAL will help keep me connected to my roots while...

profile of sniffles

Double Rainbow in Cary - Amazing

profile of aelmoutawakil

I would like to be an active member in WRAL golo website..

profile of jamesm1110

Through Christ All Things Are Possible

profile of ambidextrous cat

 I'm here to share the truth.

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

wilsonians (3 members)

Wilson people please come in!

bible readers (7 members)

This is a group designed for people who are interested in talking about topics inside our bibles....

theultimateyou (1 member)

This group is about discussing issues relating to the overall needs & well being of women and promoting...

proud parent and grandparents (8 members)

I thought of this while watching my own child playing. So this group idea comes from the heart. While...

a miracle a day (4 members)

There are miracles happening all around us, everyday. THey can either be profound or small.....

i smoke so what (11 members)

For the few of us that smoke. The non-smokers call us evil, health care robbing, tax dollar suking smelly leaches. I say my choice! nunya! Open to smokers!

pool players (3 members)

"RACK EM"

foster parent support group (2 members)

A forum for foster parents to rant/rave, voice concerns and complaints. To discuss laws/changes, that...

colts tar heels and other luvers (1 member)

Come here if you are a football lover!

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of absolut mocha

If life is like a box of chocolates, could some of those chocolates have been ex-lax in disguise?...

profile of just call me red

Builder24car- "I miss red. *sigh*" Men are like. Bananas . The older they get, the less firm they are. -sent by Bev  

profile of buckeyennc

We won that war!  All of us are Yankees now!!! 13 Year Army Vet!  Combat Engineer;...

profile of amvaugha is immaculate

I'm a mother and my daughter is my number one love and priority. I love life and I am grateful...

profile of thanos

Existence is a matter of opinion.

profile of builder24car

Life is short, have fun!   March 22nd, 2009 Bristol! Damn that's a LONG time from...

profile of dayumit sessy v--v

Show YOUR support, adopt a Soldier! http://www.adoptaussoldier.org/...