Golo
mimi29: blog

mimi29's blog


is this the correct dui punishment?

Published May. 16, 2008

"Emily Elizabeth May of Raleigh died a year ago in crash in Fayetteville. She was the passenger in a car driven by a drunken friend.[Polumbo]

Polumbo pleaded guilty in January to felony death by vehicle, reckless driving, driving while impaired and driving after consuming alcohol while under the age of 21. Judge E. Lynn Johnson sentenced her to 30 days in jail plus three years of probation. If Polumbo violates her probation, she could go to prison for 20 months." 

The above paragraphs are from the Fayetteville Observer May 16,2008  http://www.fayobserver.com/article?id=294123

I hate for a 20 year old to spend her life in jail for killing a friend, she must be punishing herself something awful.  BUT...it the punishment enough?

The article in its entirety explains how Mays family is suing all the people who served Polumbo alcohol and also Fayetteville and the camera company for mounting a 300 pound camera on a break away pole.



23 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.



page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

I like your punishments, GetRight. Think they should be applied at a lesser level to DWIs before they hurt someone.

I feel for all involved, but Ms. May did get into the car with Ms. Polumbo, I assume of her own free will. Would a harsher punishment have kept Ms. May alive? Guess we'll never know.

Bones - Thanks for mentioning that story. I never heard that but THAT'S the kind of sentencing we need to be seeing more of: creative sentences that may strike at the heart of the matter.

At a bare minimum adjustment to the sentence Polumbo should spend the rest of her life on probation. Terms: any alcohol related conviction and she serves 20 years w/o parole.

Additionally, there should be a significant term (~10-20hrs per month for 20 years) of community service serving families who have been victimized by DUI, serving in rehabs for innocent victims struck by DUI drivers, etc.

This kind of sentencing would not only keep in the forefront of her mind the impact of one foolish decision but also give her an opportunity to give back to the "community" of victims she hurt. THAT would give her the opportunity to truly repent and to deal with her guilt by giving something back.

What do ya'll think this fine morning in GoLo court?

I imagine that this girl is punishing herself more than any law could. That camera falling really is disturbing. You don't have to be a drunk driver to crash into a pole.

I know there intersection where this occured very well. The camera is in the median and there are two left turn lanes. It can be confusing. Funny how Fayettville pulled all their cameras last summer.

It doesn't say in the story whether the girl who was killed was also drinking. I would have to say if she wasn't drinking,then why wasn't she driving and if she was drinking, why leave it from the story? The passenger made a decision to get into the car with a person who had been drinking, and while the underage driver should not have been drinking, the girl knew the risks associated with riding with drunk drivers. The driver should be punished, but I think that a better punishment would be witnessing to youths about the dangers of drunk driving or ride alongs to accidents involving drunk drivers or even autopsies involving drunk drivers- something that will stick with her... As for the people who served her the alcohol, if she had a good fake ID, it would be hard to hold them at fault. But if they knowingly served a minor, then they should be punished to the full extent of the law. Bottom line, people need to make better choices and know the breath you take could be your last.

True Wiseowl, the camera falling was the defining moment. The next person who crashes into a similar pole might not be drunk. Who will be blame then? Better to deal with it now.

im normally very against frivolous lawsuits against cities, but this girl would be alive today if that 300 pound camera didn't crash through the roof. the crash itself would probably not have caused any other injuries at all.

dumb placement of the camera on fayetteville's part and poor construction.

Strolling, that's pretty interesting. I can see where that would be painful to do as it is a constant reminder of the accident...

I'm not understanding why they're suing the people who served the driver alcohol. Was the girl mentally retarded or cognitively impaired when she purchased her first drink? Did someone hold a gun to her head? Maybe the place could've checked ID better but come on...no one FORCED that driver to drink.

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Please log in to add comment.

most recent
   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

teachers: what do you love about your job?

Teachers of GOLO: Is there any one thing you absolutely love about being a teacher? As a student,...

victory

I just went the bathroom (#1) and I didn't have to use my hands at all!!!!   I was...

clarification

http://www.wral.com/news/news_briefs/story/3167055/  Touma...

who's making the money!

Many Americans are struggling to make ends meet because of $75 and $100 trips to the gas station....

geraci,marlene renee

This information is made available for purposes of protecting the public, for keeping them informed...

got fresh bread?

Ever "Wonder" if you're getting the freshest bread on the shelf? Here's some neat info....

horny?

always go to the restroom before bed time. if not /if your a guy/ this could cause a MISUNDERSTANDING!

this day in history ~ satchel paige

On 09 Jul 1948, 42 year old Leroy "Satchel" Paige made his major league debut,...

walmart slogan contest

So wally-world is running a contest for someone to come up with a new slogan for them to replace their...

cruise ship: fail

A cruise ship with 51 people on board ran aground and was stuck for about nine hours in Alaska....

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of pancake

STOP THE MADNESS

profile of med4centrl

It doesn't have to rhyme, it just has to make a difference.

profile of harrymakiester

Man with hand in pocket feel cockey all day!

profile of abastin

This was the sky over Fuquay Varina before the rain actually hit.

profile of momxs2

what is the hokey pokey really is what it's all about?

profile of scgmcck503

You must love yourself before anyone else will love you

profile of seeksthetruth73

I've always thought that life was about lessons.  Learning what we need to learn about ourselves...

profile of rstan

Freedom isn't free.

profile of callflashlight

The mind is like a parachute it only function when it open.

profile of apexcitizen

Forgiveness is grand.

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

we are teachers (6 members)

This is a group for teachers. Let's talk about our mission to educate today's youth as well as the ups and downs of our craft.

where are the sexual offenders (8 members)

We are a group of bloggers that wish to protect the children. This information is made available...

girls play (44 members)

Ok ladies. This is a place to come and and post your eye candy.

starbucks addicts (47 members)

For anyone who drinks or eats anything from Starbucks on a regular and/or daily basis. ....

golo live (19 members)

From the State Fair to the Eno River Festival, if we're there, you can be right there with us without...

bad dog (6 members)

WRAL is looking for a few bad dogs to train to be good dogs. We've already chosen six and you can...

missing children (12 members)

Posting Daily Information on Different missing children Month of July: Sunday  ...

women speak (115 members)

fashion is as fashion does (4 members)

This blog's main focus is fashion but we will touch on all aspects of the image that we project. ...

rock n roll junkies (15 members)

For people that love Rock 'n Roll as much as I do.  A place where we can review new...

   blogs    galleries    profiles    groups    popular  

profile of wizard633

drprice633@aol.com    Keep...

profile of cottontownrambler

Only boring people get bored   Video of me surf fishing at emerald isle ( no sound...

profile of dayum sessy

Have a big  ♥ ??  Adopt a US Soldier !! http://www.adoptaussoldier.org/    They...

profile of ncmomof3

 I'm just me, what you see is pretty much what you get . I'm married and have 3 boys.  My household is rounded out with 2 wonderful golden retrievers and 2 kitties. 

profile of clayton

okokok im going to take a golo break for the rest of the week. i will check this place after...

profile of packy aka kracka

" There is nothing in the world so wonderful as to love and be loved; there is nothing so devastating...

profile of gandalf rides again

I will never claim I am always right. I will just agree to agree your opinion is wrong and I have no...

profile of bosoxbaby

I'm just losin my blessed mind one day at a time...bills and my crazy tail family are takin me one...