Five questions today's primary will answer

Posted May 6, 2014

— After millions of dollars in television ads and months of political stump speeches, chicken dinners, polls and speculation, fewer than one in five eligible voters will head to the polls Tuesday if past North Carolina primaries are any guide. 

Primaries in non-presidential years tend to be some of North Carolina's lowest-turnout partisan elections. Turnout barely exceeded 20 percent in 2002, when both Republicans and Democrats were holding competitive U.S. Senate primaries. This year, Sen. Kay Hagan, a Greensboro Democrat, is virtually assured of her party's nomination, although there is a bruising primary for the Republican nomination to challenge her. 

North Carolina primary turnout for non-Presidential election years

YearVoting Age PopulationTurnoutRegistered Voters% Turnout

Among the questions voters could help answer when they head to the polls are these five: 

1) Will big money swing a normally sedate Supreme Court primary?

Non-candidate groups have spent more than $1 million in an effort to unseat sitting state Supreme Court Justice Robin Hudson. An ad accusing Hudson of being soft on child molesters has been in heavy rotation on television in the days running up to the primary. 

Normally, Hudson, an incumbent who has served in office for eight years, would enjoy an advantage in her three-way primary against Jeanette Doran and Eric Levinson. But only two candidates can emerge from the race, and it's possible the million-dollar campaign against her could keep Hudson from reaching the general election. 

2) Is the tea party strong enough to force a runoff, or will the Republican establishment get its U.S. Senate candidate? 

There's no question that state House Speaker Thom Tillis is the candidate "establishment" Republicans would like to see have the chance to take on Hagan. Gov. Pat McCrory has endorsed him, as has 2012 GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney. American Crossroads, the PAC affiliated with former President George W. Bush strategist Karl Rove, is airing commercials on his behalf, as is the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

Polls in recent weeks indicate the question for Tillis is not whether he will take home the most votes in the eight-member primary field, but whether he will take home enough votes. Unless he gets 40 percent or more of the primary electorate, Tillis will face the very high likelihood that the second-place finisher will call for a runoff. 

The most likely candidates for that second place spot are Rev. Mark Harris of Charlotte and Dr. Greg Brannon of Cary. Both Brannon and Harris hail from the more conservative tea party wing of the GOP, although Harris has more of a connection with social conservatives while Brannon fits more in the mold of the U.S. Sens. Mike Lee and Rand Paul.

3) Does stronger early voting turnout indicate a higher interest in the election or just a shift toward early voting? 

The state Board of Elections has been trumpeting figures that show more North Carolinians voted early in-person this year than they did in 2010, the last non-presidential election year. Early voting concluded Saturday with 259,590 votes cast versus 172,972 votes cast during early voting four years ago. That means nearly 4 percent of eligible voters have already cast a ballot this year versus just under 3 percent in 2010. 

Those numbers could indicate an increased interest in this year's election. Or it could just reflect a shift in habits as more voters take advantage of early voting. 

4) Will an incumbent fall? 

Incumbents generally enjoy advantages of name recognition and party loyalty when they ask voters for support. But several incumbents have faced strong challenges this year. Among the races to keep an eye on: 

  • 2nd Congressional District Republican primary: Congresswoman Renee Ellmers, once a tea party star, now faces a challenge from her conservative flank by Frank Roche, a radio talk show host. 
  • 3rd Congressional District Republican primary: Congressman Walter Jones Jr., long a brand name in eastern North Carolina politics, is fighting a three-way primary. One of his competitors, Taylor Griffin, has the backing of both one-time vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin and a deep-pocketed super PAC that has spent thousands to accuse Jones of being too liberal. 
  • State Senate District 15 Republican primary: Rep. Jim Fulgham isn't exactly an incumbent, but the state representative is Sen. Neal Hunt's hand-picked replacement. He is squaring off against Apryl Major. 
  • State House District 14 Republican primary: Rep. George Cleveland is being outspent by his GOP challenger, Bobby Mills, State Board of Elections reports show.
  • State House District 27 Democratic primary: Rep. Michael Wray is attempting to fend of a challenge from Franklin Williams, a minister who has told local newspaper writers that the incumbent has not been aggressive enough in challenging GOP policies. 

5) Will we be singing Clay's tune? 

Clay Aiken rose to fame as a singer on "American Idol" and drew attention to the Democratic primary simply by throwing his hat into the ring. 

He's now running for the chance to take on Ellmers this fall. But former state Commerce Secretary Keith Crisco has run a well-funded campaign against the Broadway star, criticizing Aiken for failing to show up when appointed to a presidential commission on children with disabilities. 

Also on the radar: Nine Republicans are vying for the GOP nomination in an increasingly nasty 6th Congressional District primary for the seat now held by retiring Congressman Howard Coble. Seven Democrats hope to take over the seat once held by 12th District Congressman Mel Watt. Voter registration in those districts heavily favors whoever emerges from those primaries, but taking more than 40 percent of the vote home Tuesday is an uphill battle for any candidate.


This blog post is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Raleigh Rocks 1 May 7, 2014

    so will y0u have an article today WRAL with these answers?

  • Raleigh Rocks 1 May 7, 2014

    View quoted thread

    Typical uninformed voter. Funniest and saddest comment of the day.

  • JustOneMoreGodThanThee May 6, 2014

    " I don't understand why, after all these years, people still see us as a monolithic voting block...I guess cause that's how democrats vote.

    Not only vote monolithicly- in todays Elon poll they all got whiplash changing their opinion on voter id when they were told what to think about the requirement.

  • Catmandu May 6, 2014

    View quoted thread

    I am not rich, and I don't want to pay more taxes. 17 trillion in debt and 130 trillion in unfunded liabilities says they have a spending problem, not an income problem.

  • Richard Wood May 6, 2014
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    I support it and I'm not rich. I'm just sick of paying more taxes. Maybe paying taxes makes me "rich"

  • BurtReynoldsBigHat May 6, 2014

    View quoted thread

    Are you aware of the irony in your statements?

    "I don't understand why, after all these years, people still see us as a monolithic voting block...I guess cause that's how democrats vote. "

    "We are united in seeing Hagan defeated."

  • John Paschall May 6, 2014
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Its funded and supported by rich people that don't want to pay taxes

  • Raleigh Rocks 1 May 6, 2014

    View quoted thread

    The objection is because Tea Party folks are a threat to dems, so they try to attack folks who simply believe we are taxed too much because they disagree with their liberal agenda. These folks are of all races and backgrounds. For example, http://blackandconservative.com

  • Raleigh Rocks 1 May 6, 2014

    View quoted thread

    Maybre so but whom do you support than can be trusted? Kay Hagen and Obama?? bwahaha

  • Catmandu May 6, 2014

    Taxed Enough Already. TEA Party. I really do not understand the objection to the TEA Party. Are you not Taxed Enough? Or is it that you think I am not taxed enough? If you want to pay more, have at it. I think I pay entirely too much as it is, and for what?