Our Five Faves

Best ice cream

Posted June 4, 2012
Updated July 8, 2012

Ice cream - a perfect summertime treat. Check out our Five Favorite spots in the Triangle to indulge in this frozen treat: 

Goodberry's Frozen Custard (various locations) - Their frozen concrete is a favorite among our staff. With so many mix-ins and custard flavors, you can try something new every time you go and never get bored. (Some of our favorite custards: Jamocha and Butter Pecan.) Goodberry's is truly a Triangle treat with locations in Cary, Durham, Raleigh and Wake Forest. The only Goodberry's outside of N.C. is in Erindale, Australia. 


Lumpy's (Wake Forest) - This North Carolina State Fair favorite only recently opened up a shop. Before, you just had to find out which festival or event they would be at each weekend. Lumpy's has the typical staples – vanilla, strawberry, chocolate – but what sets it apart is the inventive flavors constantly coming out of the "Lumpy's Lab." Some of their inventive homemade ice cream creations – bacon and bourbon and sweet potato. 

Andy's/Hwy 55 (various locations) - Andy's is changing its name to Hwy 55 so it can expand regionally, but they should just call it Frozen Custard Heaven. Their custard, made fresh at each location daily, is soft serve-style. This stuff is good all by itself, but you can add candy-bar mix-ins, chocolate syrup and other items to make it even better. And they even make shakes and floats - fitting perfect with the restaurant's 1950s diner theme. Who is up for a root beer float this afternoon? 

cook out milkshake

Cook Out (various locations) - We love Cook Out milkshakes so much, we even did a separate Five Faves about our favorite flavors. There are more than 45 flavors to choose from. One of our favorites: Peanut Butter Fudge.


Char Grill (various locations) - This Raleigh institution is known for its hamburger steak sandwiches and its awesome milkshakes. 

Honorable mention: Winston's Grille (Raleigh), where you can get fresh homemade ice cream on top of their amazing desserts. I really love their strawberry shortcake covered in fresh strawberry ice cream. 

Did we leave out any of your favorites? 


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • niblick Jul 9, 2012

    While my wife thinks only Goodberry's, I have been a fan of Lumpy's for years. Glad Buck is opening a shop at last

  • cn38of50 Jun 24, 2012

    Cold Stone - oreo overload - HEAVEN!

  • Country Girlz Have MORE fun Jun 11, 2012

    Mmmm Cook Out milk shakes.

  • cwood3 Jun 8, 2012

    Hand's down-MAPLE VIEW west of Chapel Hill!! melts in your mouth. Guarenteed to raise one's cholesterol!!

  • crypt5302 Jun 7, 2012

    With out a doubt Sunni Skies in Angier is the absolute best around. Best I have ever had.

  • pikis71722 Jun 7, 2012

    Winston's Grill makes their own. And it's yummy! Warning: Coffee Toffee will change your life!

  • nicekrispy Jun 7, 2012

    Sunni Skies and Goodberry's is where its at.

  • gocanesss Jun 6, 2012


  • Chagrined Jun 6, 2012

    Without a doubt - Spinners in Wakefield area of North Raleigh. Awesome hot fudge sundaes with numerous flavors of ice cream. Check out the Brownie with ice cream topping. AWESOME

  • BBQ hound dog Jun 5, 2012

    Maple View Farms ice cream.