Editorial: HB2 repeal will come only when Berger and Moore clear the way

Posted March 1

GOP, execs express support for HB2 repeal effort

A CBC Editorial: Wednesday, March 1, 2017; Editorial# 8130
The following is the opinion of Capitol Broadcasting Company

Repealing House Bill 2 takes just two votes – state Senate boss Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore. Once they say they’re for repeal, HB2 will be done. Rank-and-file Republicans will fall in line behind the leadership and that will be it. That is what needs to happen now.

But what does it take to get those two on board for repeal? It’s clear that the much discussed and promoted “compromise” legislation state Rep. Chuck McGrady’s pushing isn’t it.

Despite his good intentions, McGrady will likely soon discover he’s been played for a patsy by the House and Senate bosses who appear to have no appetite to repeal HB2 no matter the circumstances.

McGrady held a news conference Tuesday, featuring representatives from several key North Carolina business groups. The gathering was designed to promote his “compromise.” But what was abundantly clear was that very few, if any, of the business leaders expressed out-and-out support for McGrady’s bill.

As it stands now, the bill has more in it that is keeping different factions away, than bringing them together.

A provision allowing for local referendums to overturn nondiscrimination ordinances cities might pass is a bad idea. Voters already have an opportunity to vote out local officials if they don't like what they do. That is how our system works.

The bill includes a ridiculously low threshold – 10 percent of voters in the previous municipal election -- to get a repeal on the ballot. That would be a mere 4,200 signatures in Raleigh – a city with a 438,000 population. Such a counter-productive process only breeds more divisiveness and trouble. There will be a referendum in every city.

What was really evident at McGrady’s gathering? Unanimous support for repealing HB2. Not a repeal and replace, but find a way to repeal HB2, each speaker pleaded. They know it's not just a "bathroom bill." They all know that enshrining discrimination and bigotry in North Carolina law is a loser.  It isn’t merely the impact on our economy, the law is morally wrong.

But, thanks to extreme gerrymandering, the General Assembly has become an ideological echo chamber where voices of reason are drowned out by shouts of extremism.

It is a place where absurd comments from Moore and Berger, complaining it’s always the opponents and victims of HB2 who are preventing its repeal, are inexplicably viewed as reasonable.

As the Tuesday news conference came to a close, McGrady seemed more exasperated than energized. “I’m real pragmatic about this,” he said. “I want to get this off the table. It’s sucking all the wind out of every other issue we’ve got out.”

If McGrady is as pragmatic as he contends, he needs to find 15 more Republicans in the House and 11 in the Senate to join with the Democrats – and repeal HB2. Even better than pragmatic, it is the right thing to do.

HB2 makes it legal under North Carolina law to fire someone just because they are gay and makes it legal to refuse to serve gay people in a business. Think of the lunch counter in Greensboro.

Have the clocks stopped in the Legislative Building? This is 2017, and time to get rid of HB2.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Star Bolt Mar 29, 12:13 p.m.
    user avatar

    The majority of North Carolinians support HB2 in spite of the financial blackmail of organizations like the NCAA. It's the supporters of repeal, not the backers of HB2, that need to fear the backlash.

  • Tom Sturgis Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    You are suggesting that only ~10% of Raleigh voters cast votes (4200 of 438,000). Wake County results show that 531,000 ballots were cast by 705,000 registered voters. I have to question your math as well.

  • Judy Loftin Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    Thank you Berger and Moore!! You are standing up for North Carolina!!!!

  • Teddy Fowler Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    Funny as I heard that it was Cooper who kept the Democrats from agreeing to this last compromise.... Maybe repealing HB2 just takes one vote.... (not that he votes but you get my drift).

  • Larry Price Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    the paragraph isn't setup very well. it should mention that about 42,000 people voted in the previous election; that's where the 4,200 comes from.

  • Tom Sturgis Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    4,200 is 10% of 438,000? Someone at CBC failed math.

  • William Sherman Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    Ok--couple of things--first--NC is a right to work state--it means that a person cannot be compelled to join a union in order to get a job, or that a person can be compelled to pay union dues/fees. Hiring/firing has nothing to do with it. Secondly--these politicians and most businesses could literally care less where the members of the Alphabet Soup crowd go to pee. Their concern is with adding an extra layer of protection for business' to prevent them from being sued by the Alphabet crown for discrimination based on their sex, gender or gender identity. Federal and state laws already exist which allows suits to be filed for these conditions---they are seeking, as usual, something extra, over and above the rights enjoyed by average, normal people.

  • Ed Ray Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    That's funny they can still be fired for being gay, trans, or anything like that. This is not a right to work state. You can be fired because the boss is having a bad day or he just does not like you.

  • Sherry Reams Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    AFIK, it takes 6 votes, 3 in each House. In some circumstances the 2d and third readings can be combined. Do not know where you got one vote (reading) in each House.

  • Michael Bawden Mar 1, 2017
    user avatar

    HB2 should never be repealed when it comes to allowing opposite gender to enter lockerroom. If a person is so sure they are not the correct chromosome at birth then have the surgery. If a person is not willing to go all in, then I question their sincerity! Do you hear me Caitlyn? Dont be a victim, be a leader. Have the surgery!