Duke Energy, NC agree to $7M fine over coal ash leaks

Posted September 29, 2015

Coal ash

— Duke Energy and North Carolina environmental regulators agreed Tuesday to a $7 million fine over contaminated groundwater near all of the company's coal ash ponds statewide.

The settlement cuts by more than 70 percent a record $25.1 million fine the state Department of Environmental Quality levied in March for leaks from the ash ponds at the L.V. Sutton Steam Plant near Wilmington. The reduced amount remains the largest fine the state has ever imposed for environmental damage, officials said.

Duke had appealed the fine, claiming that the DEQ had violated its own policies and procedures in assessing it, and the two sides spent much of Monday behind closed doors trying to hammer out a deal before the appeal went before a state administrative law judge.

Officials said the settlement will accelerate the clean-up groundwater contamination at the Sutton plant as well as Duke's Asheville Plant, its H.F. Lee Plant in Goldsboro and its Belews Creek Steam Station in Forsyth County, the only plants where recent tests showed groundwater contamination had spread beyond Duke property. State officials estimated those clean-up costs at $10 million to $15 million.

“This agreement holds Duke Energy accountable for past groundwater contamination and mandates that Duke Energy expeditiously clean up polluted groundwater near its coal ash sites,” DEQ Secretary Donald R. van der Vaart said in a statement. “Our chief goal is to protect the environment and public health while requiring corrective action to restore groundwater quality.”

"We welcome the opportunity to put this issue behind us, allowing us to continue focusing on closing coal ash basins as quickly as the state process will allow," Duke officials said in a statement. "Ultimately, closing ash basins in ways that protect people and the environment will address groundwater concerns."

Safe Retest Don't drink

Explore the coal ash tests

Find out more about the state's ongoing tests of private and public wells near North Carolina's 14 coal ash locations. Click on a well marker to see the recommendations state health officials have issued in response to the tests, or select a Duke Energy plant to get an overview.

Duke two years ago paid for water lines to be extended to properties near the Sutton plant, and company officials said contamination at the Asheville, Lee and Belews Creek plans haven't affected any private wells.

Coal ash is the material that's left over when coal is burned for fuel. While much of it is inert, it does contain toxic levels of certain substances, such as thallium, mercury, lead and other materials harmful to humans and wildlife.

Environmental groups contend that both Duke and the state have known for years that the ash pond at the Sutton plant and other power plants have been leaking toxins into groundwater and nearby rivers and streams.

Duke pleaded guilty in May to violating the federal Clean Water Act in connection with leaks at several coal ash ponds across North Carolina – but not the Sutton plant – and agreed to pay $102 million in fines and restitution.

But the company argued that a 2011 state policy encouraged remediation actions for ash pond leaks in lieu of fines.

DEQ officials said Gov. Pat McCrory's administration plans to rescind the 2011 policy to clarify that state government penalize future polluters in addition to requiring clean-up of contaminated sites.

A state law adopted last year requires Duke to close down all of its ash ponds by 2029. A commission was set up to establish a priority list for the effort, but Duke has already started removing ash from several retired plants and has laid out plans to build lined landfills at the Sutton plant and at the Dan River Steam Station in Eden to contain ash.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Mike Berthold Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    You really need to check your usage because Duke has been limited to a 4.5% increase last year and a .6% increase this year. If your bill has gone up 20%, something is wrong on your end.

  • Ron Nickels Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    If they pay a fine, they need to make up the revenue. Cant beat em.

  • Ty Rammstein Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    so duke energy makes HUGE HUGE profits.they made errors and were trying to deny anything happened ( in spite of their Pr saying otherwise) and now with in rate hikes fines and clean ups the consumer pays the cost..and thats just the way it should be for this legislature.. get rid of those fools in Raleigh now..we deserve better.

  • Robert Smith Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    Looks like McCory took care of his buddies at Duke. So sad they are in bed with Duke Energy and lowered the fine by about 75%. In the long run the Duke Energy customers will be the ones to suffer from poor government decisions under McCory. SAD SAD SAD

  • John McCray Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Actually the rate increase proposed by Duke Energy in 2013 was to be phased in over a two year period. Do the math. Also, the state's AG lost the case trying to block the rate change back in January. http://www.bizjournals.com/charlotte/blog/energy/2015/01/n-c-supreme-court-upholds-duke-energys-5-1rate.html

  • Russell Chapman Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    I don't think you fully understand how energy rates work. Duke can't simply raise rates year over year. Any rate hikes go before a commission. They haven't raised rates in the last year so if your bill is higher, you used more, plain and simple.

  • Ron Coleman Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    Now I understand why my power bill is about 20% higher than it was last year at this time. I think I recall that Duke made the statement that it was going to be the rate payers that is going to foot the bill on this.

  • Ron Nickels Sep 29, 2015
    user avatar

    sounds good---We will gladly pay the rest!