Did McCrory flip-flop on 2012 abortion promise?

Posted June 5, 2015

— Critics are assailing Gov. Pat McCrory's decision to sign an abortion bill passed Wednesday by lawmakers, saying he is reneging on a promise he made as a candidate not to approve any more restrictions on access to the procedure.

House Bill 465 would triple the wait time for a woman seeking an abortion, from 24 to 72 hours after she consults with a physician. McCrory quietly signed the bill into law on Friday.

During his 2012 gubernatorial campaign, McCrory replied "none" when asked during a debate what restrictions on abortion he would support. He said this week that House Bill 465 doesn't break that promise.

"It takes a phone call to begin that process," he said of the waiting period. "Frankly, that (is the) process a lot of people use for all medical procedures.

PROMISE TRACKER Pat McCrory Promise Tracker

"The fact of the matter is, due to my work and others' work, we did not add further restrictions to access," he added.

McCrory was referring to a provision dropped before the bill made it through the Senate that would have prevented anyone other than a board-certified ob-gyn from performing an abortion. Fewer than two-thirds of North Carolina's 100 counties have certified a ob-gyn.

Even without that provision, Melissa Reed, vice president of public policy for Planned Parenthood South Atlantic, was critical of the bill. The new waiting period is among the longest in the United States, and it makes no exceptions for cases of rape or incest or if a doctor strongly advises an abortion.

"Tripling the waiting period for women seeking safe and legal abortions is a restriction. This is an arbitrary delay. It has no medical basis," Reed said. "This is absolutely a restriction, and people and voters who care about women's health across the state are going to remember this."

The bill also requires doctors who perform abortions in which the fetus is older than 16 weeks to send an image of the ultrasound and other information to the state Department of Health and Human Services. No other state requires that.

North Carolina prohibits abortions after 20 weeks, and Reed said that provision is meant to discourage doctors worried about being second-guessed as to whether they are abiding by state law.

"It will also really worry women to know that their private medical ultrasounds are going to be sent to the state. They're going to be available via a website, and even though their names are redacted, it is their private medical information," she said.

DHHS, which recently finished its own rule-making process for abortions, didn't request the ultrasound provision, spokeswoman Alexandra Lefebvre said. The agency doesn't have a radiologist on staff to read the scans, she said.

McCrory, who also was sharply criticized in 2013 for abortion-related legislation he signed into law, said the media is paying too much attention to the waiting period bill.

"My focus (is) – and I encourage your focus to be – on the issues that are most important to the people of North Carolina, and those aren’t literally the issues that are above the fold in your newspapers at this point in time," he said.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Matt Wood Jun 8, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    So I guess you don't kill and eat any plants or animals because they're "life" too, right? Otherwise, you're just playing with semantics.

  • Anthony Snark Jun 8, 2015
    user avatar

    He real question is, why did anyone believe his campaign promise?

  • George Herbert Jun 8, 2015
    user avatar

    Gov. McCrory is trying to spin his way out of the mess he created when he made the campaign promise. I find his trying to weasel his way out of this worse than what he's done. The fact that he doesn't see tripling the waiting period as a "further restriction" is ludicrous to anyone with common sense.

  • Ty Rammstein Jun 6, 2015
    user avatar

    he is and has been a liar of long standing..we knew that already. it is more than a bit annoying how flip he is about it. this man has no spine and zero leadership skills. ..a useless mess

  • Tammy Rush Jun 6, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    And he's lying about the fact that he lied.

  • Robert Richardson Jun 6, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    LOL, none of what you said matters. The issue at hand is did he lie or not. Whether you are for or against abortion, the fact of the matter is that he lied and did the exact opposite of what he said he would do.

  • Sam Nada Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    He lied. He flatly and unequivocally said he would not sign a bill that made abortion less accessible, and that's exactly what he's done. And his only defense appears to be that the news media is reporting it. It's indefensible, and he should be held accountable. Whatever he says to try and get elected again should be ignored, and this betrayal remembered.

  • Kerry Harpe Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    Well thanks for explaining that to us Gov - "My focus (is) and I encourage your focus to be on the issues that are most important to the people of North Carolina, and those aren't literally the issues that are above the fold in your newspapers at this point in time." First, you news reporters should take a bow, because if something isn't in the headlines of your or the lead story, then it just ain't important. I didn't realize that you were so influential. And, I thank you for resetting my ill-ordered priorities by defining what is important to North Carolinians.

  • Lisa Menendez Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    All I care about is the job growth... Not this mess..

  • Walter Smirth Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    He broke his promise, plain and simple.