Local News

Defense claims racism in Durham officer's shooting trial

Posted August 6, 2015

— The defense was repeatedly rebuffed Thursday as it attempted to get a mistrial declared in the case of a man accused of shooting a Durham police officer three years ago.

Officer Kelly Stewart was shot in the thigh during a confrontation with Carlos Riley Jr. following a December 2012 traffic stop. Riley claims Stewart shot himself during a struggle, and defense attorney Alex Charns accused prosecutors of withholding evidence, including a worker's compensation claim filed by Stewart.

Charns said the claim could include critical information for Riley's defense, such as statements Stewart made after he was shot, and he criticized prosecutors for not even knowing a claim was filed.

"There's the gentleman right here, the officer. She can ask him. They have a bevy of investigators," Charns told Superior Court Judge James Roberson, adding that his resources were limited by comparison. "There's just me. I've got a pen."

Roberson agreed that the defense should have access to Stewart's worker's comp claim and ordered prosecutors to track it down and hand over a copy. But he said there was nothing malicious in the prosecution's actions and denied Charns' motion for a mistrial.

A series of defense motions Thursday morning stalled the case, preventing prosecution witnesses from taking the stand until mid-afternoon.

Charns also alleged racial and ethnic bias in the case, saying he and Riley are being treated differently because he is Polish and Riley is black.

"The issue of race and not being able to afford a lawyer has infected this case," he told Roberson. "Something isn't right here."

In addition to accusing prosecutors of dragging their feet in turning over evidence, he said they prevented Riley from getting a speedy trial.

"They wouldn't do it to a white, rich defendant," he said.

Stewart also is black.

Durham County Assistant District Attorney Stormy Ellis dismissed Charns' accusations, calling the argument "just a little off."

Testimony is expected to continue Friday, and Ellis said prosecutors will likely finish their case on Monday.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Kristine Denny Aug 12, 2015
    user avatar

    Like I said in another post, why on earth would Riley run if he wasn't guilty? Secondly, my husband and I both went to school with Kelly Stewart and he wouldn't lie about something as being shot. Thirdly, seriously? Racism? Please. The defense is just trying to find any and every excuse to drag this trial out and exhaust all efforts with stupid attempts.

  • John Smith Aug 7, 2015
    user avatar

    Before now this has been viewed as "black on black" crime.. and now he's Polish and can't afford a lawyer. LOL, so I have this joke: A white man, a black man, and a..... ah never mind.

  • Travis Upchurch Aug 7, 2015
    user avatar


  • Belle Boyd Aug 6, 2015
    user avatar

    How can you play the race card when the cop and defendant are both black?

  • Honey Pointer Aug 6, 2015
    user avatar

    "Racism"--the defense of those who have no other believeable defense..Pitiful.

  • Dati Pemby Aug 6, 2015
    user avatar

    Boring. The race card is overplayed and people are desensitized to it. Facts don't work? Pull the race card. Laughable and pathetic.

    Calling someone a racist.....ha, doesn't mean much any more unless they are a card carrying member of the KKK, NAACP, Nation of islam, etc.