Government powers down; trading blame in capital

Posted October 1, 2013

— The National Institutes of Health began turning away patients for experimental treatment, and rugged Yellowstone National Park was closed to visitors as the vast machinery of government clanged into partial shutdown mode.

President Barack Obama warned that more families and businesses would be hurt if it lasted much longer, while Republicans insisted the fault was not theirs but Obama's and his fellow Democrats'.

"What we are doing now puts American lives at risk," said Sen. Dianne Feinstein, a California Democrat, warning Tuesday of the effects on intelligence agencies of a government closure that some lawmakers said could last for weeks.

"It's irresponsible that the government is shut down. I didn't get elected to come to Washington to shut the government down," said Sen. Kay Hagan, a North Carolina Democrat. "The political gamesmanship ... is certainly frustrating, and it's not what the American people expect."

At the White House, Obama unleashed a blistering attack on Republicans, accusing them of causing government's first partial closure in 17 years as part of a failed, non-stop "ideological crusade" to wipe out his signature health care law.

Republicans countered that Democrats were to blame for refusing to negotiate on Obama's health care overhaul, and they disclosed plans in the House for quick passage of measures aimed at reopening small slices of the federal establishment. The bills covered the Department of Veterans Affairs, the National Park Service and a portion of the Washington, D.C., government funded with local tax revenue.

Meanwhile, the major next step implementing the health care law was launched nationwide as Americans got their first chance to sign up in the state exchanges designed to give a first-time option to people who have no health insurance.

In Washington, some Republicans conceded privately they might bear the brunt of any public anger over the shutdown – and seemed resigned to an eventual surrender in their latest bruising struggle with Obama.

Democrats have "all the leverage and we've got none," said Sen. Saxby Chambliss of Georgia.

Dems, GOP dig in heels as government screeches to halt

"For most members of Congress, our popularity is down to family and friends, and our friends are leaving us now. So, it can't get much lower," said Sen. Richard Burr, a North Carolina Republican, whose son was furloughed from his civilian defense job because of the shutdown.

"The truth is, I'd like to have it over, but I also feel like I have a moral obligation to the next generation not to fight for nothing," Burr said.

Republican Rep. Devin Nunes of California said sardonically his party was following a "Ted Cruz-lemmings strategy" – a reference to the senator who is a prime proponent of action against the health care overhaul – and Rep. Scott Rigell of Virginia said it was time to pass legislation reopening the government without any health care impediments.

"The shutdown is hurting my district, including the military and the hard-working men and women who have been furloughed due to the defense sequester," Rigell said.

But that was far from the majority view among House Republicans, where tea party-aligned lawmakers prevailed more than a week ago on a reluctant leadership to link federal funding legislation to the Affordable Care Act. In fact, some conservatives fretted the GOP had already given in too much.

Gone is the Republican demand for a full defunding of the health care law as the price for essential federal funding. Gone, too, are the demands for a one-year delay in the law, a permanent repeal of a medical device tax and a provision making it harder for women to obtain contraceptive coverage.

In place of those items, Republicans now seek a one-year delay in the requirement for individuals to purchase insurance, and they want a separate provision that would dramatically raise the cost of health care for the president, vice president, members of Congress and thousands of aides.

Burr, who last month said shutting down the government over the health care law was among the dumbest ideas he had ever heard, on Tuesday said the one-year delay was a good bargaining position. He said there was no guarantee that Senate Democrats would ever allow a standalone vote on finding the Affordable Care Act if it is separated from the budget.

"Up to this point, we've been shut out," he said.

House Speaker John Boehner has declined to say whether he would permit a vote on a stand-alone spending bill to reopen the government, stripped of health care provisions, though Democrats and Obama continued to call on him to do so.

"He's afraid it will pass," said Sen. Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat.

"I don't think anybody should expect us to compromise or want us to compromise on our constitutional duty," said Rep. David Price, a North Carolina Democrat. "You keep the government open. That's your fundamental task. That's not up for grabs."

North Carolina Republican Rep. Renee Ellmers said the House and Senate need to meet and hash out their differences.

"That's the regular order. If we send a bill over to the Senate and they disagree with that bill, then we sit down and conference on it," Ellmers said. "That's what we're trying to achieve right now."

Cruz, a Texas Republican, the most prominent advocate of the "Defund Obamacare" movement, said the Senate should follow the House's lead and quickly reopen programs for veterans and the parks. Asked why it was appropriate to do so without demanding changes in the health care law, he offered no answer.

He spoke in a Capitol closed to regular public tours, part of the impact of a partial shutdown that sent ripples of disruption outward.

Officials said roughly 800,000 federal employees would be affected by the shutdown after a half-day on the job Tuesday to fill out time cards, put new messages on their voice mail and similar chores.

Among them were some personnel at NIH's famed hospital of last resort. Dr. Francis Collins, agency director, estimated that each week the shutdown lasts will force the facility to turn away about 200 patients, 30 of them children, who want to enroll in studies of experimental treatments. Patients already at the hospital are permitted to stay.

"None of us want to be in a shutdown, and we're here to say to the Senate Democrats, 'Come and talk to us,'" said House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, as GOP lawmakers called for negotiations with the Senate on a compromise.

It was an offer that Senate Democrats chose to refuse, saying there was nothing to negotiate until Republicans agreed to reopen the federal establishment.

"The government is closed because of the irrationality of what's going on on the other side of the Capitol," said Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.

In addition to "closed" signs and barricades springing up at the Lincoln Memorial and other tourist attractions, NASA and the Environmental Protection Agency were virtually shuttered, and Obama said veterans centers would be shut down.

"The impact is very damaging to the economy, on the American people," Price said. "There are inconveniences that become much more than just inconveniences. Eventually, you're talking about veterans' benefits, Social Security checks – the kind of basic things that people on."

Government workers classified as essential, such as air traffic controllers, Border Patrol agents and most food inspectors, remained on the job.

So, too, members of the military, whose pay was exempted from the shutdown in separate legislation Obama signed late Monday. Employees whose work is financed through fees, including those who issue passports and visas, also continued to work. The self-funded Postal Service remained in operation, and officials said the government will continue to pay Social Security benefits and Medicare and Medicaid fees to doctors on time.

At the White House, aides discussed whether Obama should change plans for a trip to Asia scheduled to begin Saturday. Staffing was reduced at the famed mansion, where a groundskeeper working outside at daybreak said he was doing the work normally handled by four.

In Congress, some aides were furloughed and others said they were working without pay. Democratic Sen. Tom Carper sent an email to his Delaware constituents telling them not to expect responses to their emails and phone calls.

Lawmakers and the president were still getting paid, however, at a rate totaling more than $250,000 per day for all of them.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Lightfoot3 Oct 3, 2013

    "Precisely who is saying flatly and openly that they REFUSE to consider ANY of the funding bills passed by the House?" - josephlawrence43

    The bottom line is that whoever put the Affordable Care Act into this mess in an attempt to squash it are responsible for the shutdown. That's Republicans.

    "This is an outright lie." - StateFan99

    Nope. The Republicans put the Affordable Care Act into the budget debate to defund it. They even admitted it. Perhaps you missed it during the reading of Green Eggs & Ham. Thus, the Republicans are responsible for the shutdown. Simple as that.

  • sunshine1040 Oct 2, 2013

    No need to trade blame the Senate and president said they will not even talk about any bill that delays a health care plan that they will not participate in but think that the folks that pay their salary should. Yep thats the taxpayers and not just the wealthy but but all that work to support their own families

  • bji Oct 2, 2013

    This gives you an idea of the lack of research and education on this act:

    Tax credits for small businesses to buy insurance: 88% in favor.

    Closing the Medicare drug benefit doughnut hole: 81% in favor.

    Extension of dependent coverage to offspring up to age 26: 76% in favor.

    Expanding Medicaid: 71% in favor.

    Ban on exclusions for preexisting conditions: 66% in favor.

    Employer mandate: 57% in favor.

    If you agree with those provisions, congratulations: You love Obamacare. Yet when respondents are asked how they feel about "Obamacare," they're against it - because they are easily manipulated/highly naive and actually believe the lies on the anti-reform ads.

  • bji Oct 2, 2013

    This is all about stopping a law that increases taxes on rich people and reduces subsidies to private insurers in Medicare in order to help low-income Americans buy health insurance. That's it. That's why the Republican Party might shut down the government and default on the debt.

    The leadership of the Republican Party agrees that the debt ceiling absolutely must be lifted. “I’m not going to risk the full faith and credit of the federal government," House Speaker John Boehner said. But they also maintain that they are willing to breach the debt limit, risking the full faith and credit of the federal government. This is a "glaring contradiction" at the heart of the GOP's position, but they never do tell the truth.

  • bji Oct 2, 2013

    "This is an outright lie. The last proposal was to simply delay the individual mandate... you know, like Obama has already decided to delay the employer mandate. They're trying to do everyone a favor who isn't ready nor wanting to purchase this. Why is it ok for Obama to delay the employer mandate but not the employee one?"

    Here is why you are dead wrong:

    In May 2007, 140 Democrats in the House of Representatives voted to defund the Iraq war. In September of the same year, Congress voted to increase the debt limit. Imagine if Nancy Pelosi and the Democrats had threatened to breach the debt ceiling unless Republicans agreed to defund the war. At that time, approval of the Iraq war was polled at 33% in favor and 64% against.

  • StateFan99 Oct 2, 2013

    So? I didn't say I agreed with the Affordable Healthcare Act. But the government shutdown is still the fault of the Republicans because they are holding government funding hostage in an attempt to defund the act."

    This is an outright lie. The last proposal was to simply delay the individual mandate... you know, like Obama has already decided to delay the employer mandate. They're trying to do everyone a favor who isn't ready nor wanting to purchase this. Why is it ok for Obama to delay the employer mandate but not the employee one?

  • 426X3 Oct 2, 2013

    Quit acting like a bunch of spoiled little brats. Get back to work.

  • josephlawrence43 Oct 2, 2013

    Lightfoot3: Might want to take another look here: Precisely who is saying flatly and openly that they REFUSE to consider ANY of the funding bills passed by the House? Who is it that flatly refused the offer of the house to form a conference committee to work out the differences? Obama/Reid. Who has openly and flatly refused to negotiate with the House, or to even talk with them?? The rank odor of a tin plated dictator named Obama is holding all the responsibility for this mess.

  • Lightfoot3 Oct 2, 2013

    "well over 50% of the American people don't want obamacare!!!" - arfamr1009

    So? I didn't say I agreed with the Affordable Healthcare Act. But the government shutdown is still the fault of the Republicans because they are holding government funding hostage in an attempt to defund the act. Simple as that. You can argue the merits of the Act all you want, or even talk about the color of the sky, but that doesn't change who's responsible for the shutdown.

  • arfamr1009 Oct 2, 2013

    not to mention the stories pouring in from people that are seeing massive cost increases all over the country...YAY OBAMA!!!! Why do liberals insist on the middle class paying for the poor to have free insurance? OBVIOUSLY they HATE the middle class citizens.