Charlotte mayor: Repealing HB2 up to state lawmakers

Posted September 19, 2016

— Mayor Jennifer Roberts quickly shot down on Monday any attempt to predicate a repeal of a state law many find discriminatory on the repeal of a Charlotte ordinance.

Legislative leaders over the weekend said they believe there is enough support in the House and the Senate to roll back House Bill 2 if Charlotte first rescinds a local law that requires businesses to allow transgender individuals to use the bathroom of their choosing.

Lawmakers passed House Bill 2 in a one-day emergency session in March to void Charlotte's ordinance, but the state law went further to exclude gay and transgender people from protections against discrimination. The state law has created a nationwide backlash with entertainers canceling concerts, organizations shifting their conventions to sites outside North Carolina and the NBA, the NCAA and the ACC all moving sporting events from the state.

The law is widely unpopular statewide and has become a drag on Gov. Pat McCrory's re-election campaign, according to the results of an Elon University Poll released Monday.

House Bill 2 Complete coverage: House Bill 2 Nearly 50 percent of those surveyed oppose House Bill 2, compared with almost 40 percent who support it. More than a third of respondents said they were less likely to vote for McCrory in November because of his handling of the issue. Still, McCrory has a slight lead of 48.7 percent to 46 percent over his Democratic challenger, Attorney General Roy Cooper.

About three-fifths of respondents said House Bill 2 has hurt North Carolina's reputation, while only 11.4 percent said it has helped. Twenty-three percent said it has made no difference.

Elon polled 644 likely voters across the state last week, and the survey has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.86 percentage points.

McCrory was prepared, a spokesman said, to call lawmakers back to Raleigh this week for a special session if Charlotte repealed its ordinance, but Roberts said the City Council wasn't going to add a repeal vote to the agenda for its Monday night meeting.

"The City of Charlotte continues its commitment to be a welcoming community that honors and respects all people. We appreciate the state wanting to find a solution to the challenges we are facing and applaud the governor for recognizing the state should overturn HB2, which the state can do at any time without any action from the City of Charlotte," Roberts said in a statement. "We urge the state to take action as soon as possible and encourage continued dialogue with the broader community."

Political finger-pointing ensues

Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore criticized Roberts' "hasty dismissal of a reasonable proposal" and suggested Cooper was working behind the scenes to scuttle the deal.

"It makes me question if she and Roy Cooper are really serious about trying to find a solution, or if they would rather prolong this debate for political reasons, regardless of the impact on Charlotte and our state’s business community," Berger, R-Rockingham, said in a statement. "If the Charlotte City Council doesn't trust the legislature will rescind HB2 once Charlotte repeals its bathroom ordinance, then it could simply pass a repeal of the bathroom ordinance that is only effective if the legislature repeals HB2."

"It now seems clear that, all along, Mayor Roberts and Roy Cooper have been engaging in political theater to the detriment of the entire state," Moore, R-Cleveland, said in a statement. "This explains why they have refused to heed the calls to act from the business community and from people on all sides of the political spectrum."

The state Republican Party also accused Cooper of working against the repeal deal but offered no evidence to support its claim.

"(Roberts) has chosen along with Roy Cooper the petty politics of today rather than making North Carolina a better place for tomorrow," GOP executive director Dallas Woodhouse said.

Cooper's campaign responded by ridiculing the allegation and saying that he has had no contact with any Charlotte City Council member in recent days.

"The legislature's trying to point the finger somewhere else when we all know that the reason we've had problems, be it with sporting events, performers or business industry, is HB2," said Chris Brook, legal director for the North Carolina chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, which has sued the state over the law.

"We shouldn't be taking anti-discrimination measures off the books," Brook said, "but if the legislature were so inclined and was really worried about the Charlotte ordinance, they certainly have it in their power to invalidate that ordinance along with repealing House Bill 2."

Shelly Carver, a spokeswoman for Berger, said the General Assembly isn't interested in nullifying the Charlotte ordinance.

"The Charlotte City Council started this debate with its bathroom ordinance, and its members have a responsibility to come to the table and work toward a resolution," Carver said.

"Charlotte started this. Charlotte needs to start with the change to fix it if they think there’s been a problem," Moore said. "They’ve tried to make this about discrimination. It’s not about discrimination. It’s about basic privacy and protection and, frankly, common sense. But they’ve tried to twist it around."

Asked whether he now thinks House Bill 2 was a mistake, Woodhouse said Republican leaders were forced into it.

"It was absolutely a huge mistake for the city of Charlotte to thrust this on the people of North Carolina. It was a monumental mistake. I don't think our legislature and the governor had any choice," he said.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Rick Nolte Sep 21, 2016
    user avatar

    Stand strong Charlotte! Let the reasonable people prevail and hate fail. If I were Gov. Pattiemelt I would start getting some boxes together to pack up my office.

  • Mike Voiland Sep 21, 2016
    user avatar

    The state of NC has near full power, via the state constitution, to negate/overule any local ordinance. The NCGA and governor can essentially repeal the Charlotte action themselves. They created this mess with the enacting of HB2, and should be the ones to end it. They are just trying to portray Charlotte as the culprit; if Charlotte was to repeal its ordinance, the NCGOP will just offer that as their "proof" that the city over-reached and was in the wrong. Stand strong, Charlotte!

  • Jack Reason Sep 21, 2016
    user avatar

    Wouldn't trust that Elon poll, by the way. Poll of Polls has a dozen polls with Hillary leading, Fox included, and Rasmussen Trump +1, while Elon is Trump +2. Participants would therefore seem to be biased Republican.

  • Clarence Hill Sep 20, 2016
    user avatar

    Governor/NCGA hold tight; remember NC's good name, integrity, honor and family values are not for sale. Don't let Charlotte's Mayor Roberts and her bunch tarnish/degrade NC's good life/heritage. There are 28 states that have laws simular to HB-2. (Where will all these games be played? They can't play them all in NY.) Remember, there is no price-tag to equal the sacred value of a little girl flushed into the hands of a predator.

  • Stacie Hagwood Sep 20, 2016
    user avatar

    Every time Berger, Moore and McCrory open their mouths about HB2, they regress in age. They are about 4 years old now

  • Lee Rogers Sep 20, 2016
    user avatar

    I think this is hilarious - the Legislature is like an abusive spouse saying "why do you make me hit you"!
    They had a kneejerk reaction that no one thought through, rushed a bill w/o any consideration of the consequences, and now want to blame Charlotte for passing a very simple non-discrimination ordinance. If the legislature would have been quiet and not chosen to make a political issue out of this, we would not have heard a peep about the ordinance and we would not be in this mess. Nor would we have become the laughing-stock of the country.

    Pat, Phil, Tim , suck down your pride, repeal HB2, and get on to serious business like grownups. I bet you won't be able to do it, because you would rather pander to your base than govern this state.

  • Matt Clinton Sep 20, 2016
    user avatar

    People say that there was never a bathroom problem before HB2. So why then did Charlotte stick its nose into the issue in the first place? If HB2 had no purpose then neither did Charlotte's ordinance. You can't say one was necessary and say one wasn't. They both need to go away, and legislators of all stripes need to stay out of our bathrooms.

  • Judy Loftin Sep 20, 2016
    user avatar

    McCrory has both Democrats and Republicans vote because of the law. Stand strong McCrory!!

  • Wayne Talley Sep 19, 2016
    user avatar

    Charlotte is trying hard to become the San Francisco of the East coast.

  • Amy Whaley Sep 19, 2016
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Go back and reread my post.... your comment seems to assume that I said something that I didn't say.