More than $98B in improper government payments

Posted November 18, 2009

— More than $98 billion in taxpayer dollars spent by government agencies was wasted, much of it on questionable claims for tax credits and Medicare benefits, representing an increase of $26 billion from the previous year.

In all, about 5 percent of spending in federal programs in fiscal year 2009 was improper, according to new details of a government financial report that were released Tuesday. Saying the overall error rate was similar in 2008, officials attributed the $26 billion jump to some changes in how to define improper spending as well as an increase in overall spending due to the recession.

President Barack Obama is expected to sign an executive order within the next week aimed at cracking down on government waste and fraud, particularly in Medicare and other benefit programs. In the 2009 report, the government officially reported questionable Medicare payments of roughly $36 billion, but that amount will be revised upward to about $48 billion next year as the Health and Human Services Department fully converts to a new methodology that imposes stricter documentation requirements.

"We need to protect taxpayer dollars," Peter Orszag, director of the Office of Management and Budget, told reporters. "Every dollar that goes to the wrong recipient or in the wrong amount is a dollar not available to help an unemployed worker, or to invest in education or key priorities of the administration."

Under the executive order, every federal agency would have to maintain a Web site that tracks improper payments, error rates and outstanding payments. If an agency doesn't meet targets for reducing error rates for two years in a row, the agency director and responsible official will have to directly report to OMB to explain the delinquency and new actions they will take.

The Obama administration will also seek to impose penalties on government contractors that receive improper payments so they have incentives to return the money, Orszag said.

Among the reported waste:

-Agriculture: $4.3 billion in improper payments, or 5.9 percent of total department spending. Much of it was in the food stamp, federal crop insurance and school meals programs.

-Defense: $849 million, or 0.5 percent.

-Education: $599 million, or 2.1 percent.

-Health and Human Services: $55.1 billion, or 9.4 percent. That included improper payment rates of 7.8 percent and 15.4 percent in the Medicare fee for service and Advantage programs, respectively.

-Homeland Security: $644.5 million, or 3.7 percent. Much of it was in the Homeland Security grant program as well as Disaster Relief Fund Vendor Payments.

-Housing and Urban Development: $1 billion, or 3.5 percent. All of it was attributed to public housing and rental assistance.

-Labor: $12.3 billion, or 9.9 percent. Almost all of the improper payments were in the unemployment insurance program.

-Treasury: $12.3 billion, or 25.5 percent. All of it was attributed to improper payments in the earned income tax credit.

-Transportation: $1.5 billion, or 3 percent. Much of it was in the Federal Highway Administration planning and construction program.

-Veterans Affairs: $1.2 billion, or 2.7 percent. That included improper payments in the pension and other compensation programs.

-Social Security Administration: $8.0 billion, or 1.2 percent.

Sen. Tom Carper, D-Del., who chairs a Senate panel on federal financial management, said he worried that the latest numbers "may still be just the tip of the iceberg" since they don't include estimates for several programs such as the Medicare prescription drug plan.

"It goes without saying that these results would be completely unacceptable in the private sector, as they should be in government, especially at a time of record deficits," Carper said.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • whatusay Nov 18, 2009

    Our congressmen/women want to stay in office and are afraid to keep raising taxes. So what do they do? They borrow from China. Only problem, that is a tax increase because we the tax payers will have to pay China back. Very tricky people.

  • colliedave Nov 18, 2009

    This story proves the government cannot run a program w/o massive fraud and outright waste of our tax dollars. And we want to trust the government to handle one-sixth of our economy by turning health care over to its control?

  • blueridgerunner Nov 18, 2009

    What did you expect from government whose very hiring practices are questionable. When you hire people based on ethnicity and gender to meet quotas set by the Federal government you get a bus load of ignorant, inept and unqualified people who either can't perform their duties properly or are just looking for a pay check. Say it aint so. The government then creates a massive bureaucracy around every department, agency, and service and fills them with these employees. On top of all this we elect people to office based on their ethnicity, looks, the party they are associated with without regard to real qualifications. These people are then put in place to make rules and regulations and oversee the departments, agencies and services. Most of them are only looking for an opportunity to gain wealth and power through connections and associations. These elected officials then appoint people like relatives, friends, business associates, girl friends and boyfriends, etc. jobs. And it repeats.

  • whatusay Nov 18, 2009

    The US Government could not run a booth at a flea market without going broke. They would have to hire 25 employees to run it, and then wonder why they can't break even.

    The government does not have any money, except what they take from tax payers. They don't produce anything. They only know how to take money and waste it. That is their sole purpose, to spend money they don't have. But, if you listen, they believe the money they are spending belongs to the government.

  • josephlawrence43 Nov 18, 2009

    Now stories such as this really inspire a lot of confidence in PrezBo and his Obamaites and their handling of the tazpayers money. Short story here: famous institution out in Nevada--admittedly a "sportin house"-was not paying its back taxes so it closed. The Gummit took over and tried to run it. They failed. This is the same bunch of hammertoed pea brains to whom we are being asked to entrust $1 TRILLION dollars to run health care? These idiots could not make money running a house of ill repute and selling booze. Not a confidence building idea now is it??

  • quebholder Nov 18, 2009

    Fraud in government payments to the tune of 98 billion...I am shocked! All the more reason to NOT have this proposed Health Care Reform as it is written.