Obama tells Congress to cut taxes in his jobs plan

Posted September 8, 2011
Updated September 9, 2011

— Attacking a deepening jobs crisis, President Barack Obama challenged a reluctant Congress Thursday night to urgently pass a larger-than-expected $450 billion plan to "jolt an economy that has stalled." He urged lawmakers to slash Social Security taxes for tens of millions of Americans and for almost every business to encourage hiring.

"Stop the political circus," an animated Obama told a joint session of Congress in a nationally televised speech. Over and over he implored lawmakers to "pass this jobs bill."

Open to discussion but making no promises, Republican House Speaker John Boehner said Obama's ideas would be considered but the president should give heed to Republicans' as well. "It's my hope that we can work together," he said.

In announcing a plan heavy on the tax cuts that Republicans traditionally love, Obama sought to achieve multiple goals: offer a plan that could actually get through a deeply divided Congress, speed hiring in a nation where 14 million are out of work, shore up public confidence in his leadership and put Republicans on the spot to take action.

The fate of economy will define Obama's re-election bid, but he sought to dismiss that element as political fodder that means nothing to hurting Americans.

Obama never estimated how many jobs would be created by his plan, which also includes new federal spending for construction, hiring and an extension of jobless benefits for the long-term unemployed. Despite his promise that it would all be paid for, he has not yet released the details on how.

His message was unmistakable to the point of repetition, as he told Congress more than 15 times in one way or another to act quickly. That was meant as direct challenge by a Democratic president to the Republicans running the House to get behind his plan, especially on tax cuts, or be tarred as standing in the way.

The urgency of the jobs crisis is as pronounced as it's been since the early days of Obama's term. Employers added zero jobs last month. A whopping number of Americans — about eight in 10 — think the country is headed in the wrong direction and Obama's approval ratings are on the decline.

In the House chamber, Obama received a warm response but then the usual political pattern took hold, Republicans often sitting in silence on the applause lines that had Democrats roaring. Boehner had chummy moments with Vice President Joe Biden at his side before the speech but was somber over Obama's shoulder as the president spoke.

"The people of this country work hard to meet their responsibilities. The question tonight is whether we'll meet ours," Obama said. "The question is whether, in the face of an ongoing national crisis, we can stop the political circus and actually do something to help the economy."

The newest and boldest element of Obama's plan would cut the Social Security payroll tax both for tens of millions of workers and for employers, too.

For individuals, that tax has been shaved from 6.2 percent to 4.2 percent for this year but is to go back up again without action by Congress. Obama wants to deepen the cut to 3.1 percent for workers.

Obama would also apply the payroll tax cut to employers, halving their taxes to 3.1 percent on their first $5 million in payroll. Businesses that hire new workers or give raises to those they already employ would get an even bigger benefit: On payroll increases up to $50 million they would pay no Social Security tax.

Obama proposed spending to fix schools and roads, hire local teachers and police and extend unemployment benefits. He proposed a tax credit for businesses that hire people out of work for six months or longer, plus other tax relief aimed as snaring bipartisan support in a time of divided government.

The White House put the price tag of Obama's plan at $447 billion, with about $253 billion in tax cuts and $194 billion in federal spending.

The president said he would make his case to the public and will waste no time taking his sales pitch on the road. His first stop will be on Friday at the University of Richmond in the Virginia congressional district of House majority Leader Eric Cantor, a frequent critic of the president's policies.

Politics shadowed every element of Obama's speech. He appealed to people watching on TV to lobby lawmakers to act. He did the same thing before his speech in an email to campaign supporters, bringing howls of hypocrisy from Republicans who wondered why Obama was telling them to put party above country.

The American public is weary of talk and wary of promises that help is on the way.

And the window for action is shrinking before the 2012 presidential election swallows up everything.

Under soaring expectations for results, Obama sought to put himself on the side of voters who he said could not care less about the political consequences of his speech. "The next election if 14 months away," Obama said, adding that the people who hired every elected leader in the room need help "and they need it now."

Administration officials bristle whenever critics of their original stimulus plan note that it did not live up to the job creation estimates the White House issued in 2009. As a result, the White House is leaving it to outside economists to render their verdict on the new plan.

Mark Zandi, one of several economists asked by the White House to evaluate the president's proposal ahead of his speech, said that if enacted it would add 1.9 million jobs and reduce the unemployment rate by one percentage point. Zandi, chief economist for Moody's Analytics, said the expanded payroll tax cut would be responsible for the most increase in hiring, adding about 750,000 jobs. The tax cut for employers, he said, would add about 300,000 new jobs

As to paying for it, Obama will ask a special debt panel in Congress to find enough savings to cover the costs of his ideas. He says he'll release specifics a week from Monday along with a proposal to stabilize the country's long-term debt. Among them: raise taxes on the wealthy, an idea Republicans have already rejected.

Most of the $447 billion package would be spent in 2012. The White House says Obama's as-yet-unrevealed plan for payment would spread the cost over the long term, likely over 10 years.

The president said deepening the payroll tax cut would save an average family making $50,000 a year about $1,500 compared to what they would if Congress did not extend the current tax cut.

"I know some of you have sworn oaths to never raise any taxes on anyone for as long as you live," Obama said, a reference to the conservative tea party influence on many House Republicans. "Now is not the time to carve out an exception and raise-middle class taxes, which is why you should pass this bill right away."

No incumbent president in recent history has won re-election with the unemployment rate anywhere near the current 9.1 percent.

Obama's jobs plan put a special emphasis on the long-term unemployed — those who have been out of work for six months or more. He repeated his calls for a one-year extension of unemployment insurance in order to prevent up to 6 million people from losing their benefits, and he proposed a $4,000 tax credit for businesses that hire workers who have been out of work for more than six months.

U.S. Sen. Richard Burr, R-NC, said he intends to consider Obama's suggestions.

"Those that achieve the threshold of stability and predictability businesses have insisted they need to invest in job creation will live for a more extensive debate in Congress. Those that are just a repackaged temporary program should be and will be discarded. This is not about how much Washington can spend, but how we create a common-sense partnership with businesses to grow our economy," Burr said in a statement.

U.S. Sen. Kay Hagan, D-NC, said she agrees with Obama's jobs plan.

"With 10 percent unemployment in North Carolina, jobs are priorities one, two and three for me,” Hagan said in a statement. “As we tackle the jobs crisis, it is imperative that we focus on practical solutions that will gain bipartisan support and actually reach the President’s desk."

U.S. Rep. G.K. Butterfield, D-NC, believes Obama is on the right track.

"I am pleased with his proposal to make crucial investments in education and infrastructure; investments that must not be delayed. The American Jobs Act will create jobs, provide a much needed jolt to our ailing economy and provide small businesses and hardworking Americans with the tools they need to compete in the 21st century economy," Butterfield said in a statement.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • FE Sep 9, 2011

    "How long is long enough for unemployment benefits?...I've asked this many times before and never gotten an answer. They were extended to 99 weeks just a few months ago, and now he wants to go another year? What happens in a year? Do we add another year? 2 years? 5 years?" -- beachboater

    ANSWER: At least through the next Presidential election, apparently.

    Rest assured there are many folks out there who are gaming the unemployment system, supposedly until the "right" job comes along. Toss in a lack of the necessary job skills (another separate topic) and the path to finding a desirable job gets longer.

    In many cases you might even call it welfare Plan B.

  • beachboater Sep 9, 2011

    How long is long enough for unemployment benefits?

    I've asked this many times before and never gotten an answer. They were extended to 99 weeks just a few months ago, and now he wants to go another year? What happens in a year? Do we add another year? 2 years? 5 years?

    How long do you pay unemployment benefits?

  • beachboater Sep 9, 2011

    Bottom line, under the Obama jobs plan, after congress cuts taxes that Obama wants, there will be a $450,000,000,000 increase in taxes. This of course will come from wealthy individuals thata think they are not paying enough and from wealthy corporations making big bucks.

    Then according to the Obama plan, after encouraging collective bargaining and increasing taxes, he thinks we can compete globally on automotive sales. He wants to increase the cost of the products that we manufacture, especially cars, and then be able to sell Chevy, Ford and Chrysler products to Korea and Japan.

    We can't compete now, and he thinks we can increase our costs and then be competitive. I give him an F minus in economics 101.

  • Lerxst Sep 9, 2011

    "Something tells me that Republicans won't support tax cuts when its for middle class workers. Millionaires and billionaires yes, but Joe the plumber, no."

    That something would be your closed mind.

  • Arapaloosa Sep 9, 2011

    I'm actually glad to see Obama has enough sense to sacrifice Social Security. It's about time that failure was defunded. I'm all for reducing tax burden, and even if a socialist brings it up, I'll applaud.

  • Ripcord Sep 9, 2011

    "Spoken by a true republican. Let's be grateful that their throwing crumbs our way when their all eating steak."

    LOL! Class envy at its best!

    Who is preventing you from eating steak?

  • MakoII Sep 9, 2011

    duster 340,

    Who BETTER to get to head a commission that a guy whom is thoroughly NOT a "socialist", respected by conservatives, and knows WHY he moved jobs elsewhere and what would bring them BACK to America.

    Whom would you appoint? A college professor?!? Robert Reisch? Or a CEO who COULDN'T figure out how to make his business more profitable by moving jobs overseas, but somehow has great business acumen for public policy?!?

    Jeff Immelt's hire is pure genius. A non-intuitive but totally LOGICAL maneuver to solve a huge problem for America.

  • snshine62d Sep 9, 2011

    "Let's all vote for Rick Perry so we can all work at McDonalds."

    That beats voting for Obama and not working at all.

    Spoken by a true republican. Let's be grateful that their throwing crumbs our way when their all eating steak.

  • Ripcord Sep 9, 2011

    "Let's all vote for Rick Perry so we can all work at McDonalds."

    That beats voting for Obama and not working at all.

  • duster 340 Sep 9, 2011

    it's not a PLAN until it's MORE than a speech - you know, written down in non-teleprompter fashion??