919 Beer

919 Beer

Battle brewing between craft beer makers, distributors

Posted March 28

— Kristie Nystedt wasn't initially sold on the idea of turning her husband's home brewing hobby into a business.

"It just seemed unimaginable and quite risky," Nystedt said during an interview in her office just off the side from Raleigh Brewing's tap room, which is tucked behind the intersection of Hillsborough and Gorman streets.

She was working in finance for a medical software company, and her husband is a pilot for a major airline, so they didn't exactly have a ton of extra time on their hands. Then, her company faced a merger, and American Airlines faced bankruptcy.

"That was when I thought, 'It's more risky not to bet on ourselves,'" Nystedt said.

That bet has paid off.

Raleigh Brewing is part of a burgeoning craft brewing scene in Raleigh and one of nearly 200 small breweries across the state. While virtually all of those brewers would rather concentrate on filling kegs and glasses with good brew, they're making a push for big changes to the state's alcohol laws and, in the process, picking a fight with the state's politically powerful beer wholesale and distribution companies.

Small brewers like Raleigh Brewing have banded together through the North Carolina Craft Brewers Guild, a local trade group, and Craft Freedom, a group put together to challenge North Carolina's beer distribution laws.

Specifically, craft brewers would like to raise the cap on the amount of beer they can distribute without working with a wholesaler, a company that acts as a middleman between beer producers and bars, restaurants and other points of sale. Under current law, once a brewery sells 25,000 barrels of beer per year – one barrel is about 330 12-ounce beers – it can no longer deliver its own product.

"I don't want to be told what to do with my business," Nystedt said. "I have invested so much money and so much time in building this business, Raleigh Brewing. I care significantly about this business and all the people that I hire."

The problem is more imminent for John Marrino, founder and owner of Olde Mecklenburg Brewery, the first craft brewery established in Mecklenburg Country. He says he's created 133 jobs over seven years.

Marrino's company has 15 employees that handle its sales and distribution in the Charlotte area. He has no desire to enter other markets, he said, noting the company is barely keeping up with demand.

"This year, I'm on a run rate to exceed this cap and have to dramatically change my business plan," he said. "We would prefer not to do that."

Marrino and the small brewers are bucking a "Three Tier System" that dates back to the post-Prohibition era. The idea of inserting a mandatory layer between alcohol manufacturers and sellers was to ensure that excise taxes would be properly collected and to put a brake on large breweries' ability to push their products at the expense of public health.

At least two measures raising the self-distribution limit on breweries have been filed this year. The most prominent, House Bill 500, which Reps. Chuck McGrady, R-Henderson, and Jon Hardister, R-Guilford, filed Tuesday, would raise the self-distribution limit from 25,000 barrels to 200,000 barrels, in addition to making a number of smaller changes to benefit small brewers, such as allowing a tap room to sell products that are not made in house.

"My interest is in wanting to remove the burdensome red tape and nonsensical limit on the growth of the craft beer industry," McGrady said at a press conference Tuesday.

Small brewers argue that the system that once kept big beer in check is now giving large brewers an advantage. Because North Carolina's 28 wholesalers move so much product from national companies, there's little incentive for them to pay attention to smaller beer makers.

Marrino said the average distributor has hundreds of beers in its portfolio and is more likely to push retailers and restaurants to stock the ones with more clout and a larger contract than beers from a small local outfit.

"We become an 'also-brand,'" Marrino said.

"I have 650 restaurants carrying my products," he said. "Frankly, if I was in a distributor's portfolio with 980 other brands, I'd be lucky if I had 100 restaurants carrying my beer."

"Breweries know they are their best salespeople," said Margo Knight Metzger, director of the North Carolina Craft Brewers Guild. "You can't expect a wholesaler to sell that beer for you. It's a lot of hard work and tooting your own horn."

But Tim Kent, executive director of the North Carolina Beer and Wine Wholesalers, says the small breweries pushing for a barrel limit increase are merely trying to upend the system for their own benefit. While his members are worried about losing business, he said, they're also worried about changing state Alcoholic Beverage Control laws in ways that benefit a few firms in the short run but engender long-term chaos.

"By creating a special privilege for a select few breweries, you're opening the door to a legal fight," Kent said.

An expanding limit for existing craft brewers could open the door to big companies being able to make an end-run around the wholesaling system, he said, citing the case of Arizona-based Four Peaks Brewing Co., which lobbied for an expansion of that state's self-distribution limit and then sold to Anheuser-Busch In Bev. The international company then inherited the craft brewer's privileges.

Most craft brewers sell around 7,000 barrels of beer a year or less. Only three makers that don't currently use distributors – Olde Mecklenburg Brewery, Guilford County's Red Oak and Charlotte's NoDa – are approaching the current limit.

"Who is really the beneficiary of this?" Kent asked.

"Alcohol is not baseball gloves or widgets," he argued. "Alcohol is a unique product. It is a controlled substance much like tobacco and pharmaceuticals. It is regulated and it is highly taxes for a reason."

Nystedt doesn't argue her business is highly regulated. However, she said, the ability to keep operating within the law is all the incentive Raleigh Brewing needs to pay nearly a quarter-million dollars per year in various taxes – with no wholesalers involved.

Those taxes will grow, craft brewers argue, if their businesses are allowed to grow without being forced to rely on an outside company.

"The biggest value-add a distributor provides is to a non-local brewery," Marrino said. "If we're going to be local breweries here in North Carolina, you have to ask the question, how does a distributor justify the 25 to 30 percent margin he's going to take from the brewer? Does he add that value? And the answer, unfortunately, is 'no' for a local brewery."

This fight is more than philosophical.

Although the wholesalers association is small itself, it has nine contract lobbyists at its disposal, including former House Speaker Harold Brubaker, former Republican Party Chairman Tom Fetzer and former Senate Rules Chairman Tom Apodaca. Democracy North Carolina, a good-government watchdog group, has reported that the association's political action committee and various industry executives contributed nearly $1.5 million to political campaigns over the past four years.

"We are family-owned companies that have been in existence, in most cases, two to three generations," Kent said. "We have long been an active player in North Carolina politics. This is a regulated industry. In the same way that other regulated businesses have an interest in the legislature, so have we."

This year, however, the craft brewers are flexing their muscle, too, says Metzger with the Craft Brewers Guild.

"This is the first time that the full weight of the Brewers Guild, which represents nearly 200 craft breweries, has been behind this issue," she said. "When you couple that with this issue-based group, Craft Freedom, we have a stronger voice than we've ever had before. This is not a small industry anymore."


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Malakai Bluebone Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    No one is forced to unless you go over a certain limit or choose to go into areas outside of your normal reach.

    Distribution is typical in almost every industry. Could you imagine what would happen if every company that produced something tried to go out and deliver it as well? Traffic would be insane, stores would be receiving 24 hrs a day for every little thing they carried.

    Distributors are essential in every aspect of life. Medical supplies are distributed, paper goods, grocery stores get deliveries from distributors, just about everything you use in every day life comes through a distributor. It is the only way for companies to do business in states where they do not have a presence. It is not an antiquated system, it is an extremely important aspect of sales that allow consumers to get products at decent prices. Imagine what prices would be like if all companies had to pay for a fleet of trucks, planes and ships to deliver.

  • Catherine Edwards Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    What other industry are you forced to use another company to handle your product. I see this as an antiquated system.

  • Malakai Bluebone Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Lots of distributors are local entities as well, NC only businesses. There are some that are multi-state operations but most out of state distributors choose not to do business in states like NC whose laws make it difficult at best for multi state operations to be able to work within.

  • Jim Frei Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    If I want a craft beer, I'll go to their brew pub and buy a pint or two. I'll never buy a six pack of a craft beer because when I'm drinking for quantity, I go with Mich Ultra or Corona. Half the craft beers out there are pure kaka and will never sell 25K barrels.

  • Malakai Bluebone Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Distribution is not brewers. You may see delivery vehicles with a name on them going down the road but they are all distributors with an ad for a product they distribute on the side of their trucks. Next time take a look and you will see the name of the distributor on the door of the truck. AB/Inbev does not distribute their beer, there are actually several distributors that do across NC.

  • Malakai Bluebone Mar 29, 2017
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Distributors see the end coming for them? From local craft brews? I really don't see that as a possibility considering several factors. 1 is that distributors were distributing before the craft beers were there, so apparently succesfull without those craft brews. 2 is that distributors aren't brewers. Most distributors are associated with brands only because NC is a control state and regulates where brands can be sold and by whom. 3, most distributors do more wine than beer. There are several more but those are some highlights.

    Craft breweries who choose to work with a distributor also win out. They get an already established distribution system without any out of pocket expense. They get access to places they could not go on their own depending on the distributor they choose, as well as knowledgeable sales staff to promote them. Win/win for both.

    Lots of craft brews can't handle the production required and fold.

  • Pope Yam Mar 28, 2017
    user avatar

    Well if big distribution brews something more interesting than for the masses of bland

  • Adam Hatch Mar 28, 2017
    user avatar

    I can't think of a single reason to oppose private craft brewers the ability to conduct good business and make money. Prohibition era laws? Are you serious? Distributors want to keep a monopoly as long as they can. Distributors can see the end coming for them. That's their real crisis.

  • Sheila Rohrbach Mar 28, 2017
    user avatar

    when you start messing with the big boys,,,it causes waves! I support anything from local so I applaude their effort

About this Blog:

Get the inside track on all things beer in the Triangle and North Carolina from the 919 Beer blog.