A candidate was hired for a job I was more qualified for. Can you offer some insight on what I can do?
Question: My question is, If an organization advertise a job opening and give detail requirements for the candidates to have before being considered. Then select a person who does not meet the minimum requirements, but I met and exceeded all requirements but was not selected and when I asked the employer about how they could select someone who did not meet the advertised requirements. They would not give a reason for this selection. They required the candidate to have a certification, which this candidate did not have, but again I had this certification and has had it for five years, plus four years experience in the same job which was advertised. My question is, do I have any legal rights to a possible civil suit against this employer, which is a county agency. Job was posted in the News and Observer with detail requirements to apply. My understanding is that if you do not meet the rquirements for any job by the closing date. You cannot be considered for this selection. Another thing ! they allowed the selected candidate to get the certification four months after he was given the job. Yes there is a EEOC complaint pending which the agency only reason for selected this candidate is that he has been with the agency for five years, but do not mention any college degrees,documented training or experience which would lead a reasonable person to select this person over me. Please give me some insight on what actions could be taken.
Answer: First, your example is unclear. You probably should talk to an experienced attorney who does government employee law and civil rights law. I cannot give you any concrete advice because your fact pattern is conflicting and very incomplete. Did you file the civil rights complaint in the form of an EEOC charge or did the person who got the job. When was the charge filed and what was the basis of the charge. You may have a standing problem. Standing is the legal concept close to "do you personally have the right to file the suit." Different rules of standing can apply to federal state and local government jobs. How can you prove that you would have gotten the job if the successful candidate was required to vacate the job. There are not cases in North Carolina that allow local government employees to be de-tenured because they were arguably disqualified at the time of hire but obtain the necessary credentials shortly after receiving the job. You have a tough case that will be hard to win and I am not sure an hardworking attorney without requiring you to pay for her or his services on an hourly basis. You may not be able to afford to win your case. Good luck.
Answer: First, your example is unclear. You probably should talk to an experienced attorney who does government employee law and civil rights law. I cannot give you any concrete advice because your fact pattern is conflicting and very incomplete. Did you file the civil rights complaint in the form of an EEOC charge or did the person who got the job. When was the charge filed and what was the basis of the charge. You may have a standing problem. Standing is the legal concept close to "do you personally have the right to file the suit." Different rules of standing can apply to federal state and local government jobs. How can you prove that you would have gotten the job if the successful candidate was required to vacate the job. There are not cases in North Carolina that allow local government employees to be de-tenured because they were arguably disqualified at the time of hire but obtain the necessary credentials shortly after receiving the job. You have a tough case that will be hard to win and I am not sure an hardworking attorney without requiring you to pay for her or his services on an hourly basis. You may not be able to afford to win your case. Good luck.
Copyright 2011 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
- I was fired because of personal e-mails on my work computer. Is this an invasion of privacy? Posted: February 13, 2007
- I feel like I have been discriminated against because of a disability. What should I do? Posted: February 13, 2007
- hat is the statute of limitations on action regarding wrongful termination by an employer? Posted: February 13, 2007
0 Comments
Featured Blogposts
American Idol and Garner native Scotty McCreery performs at N.C. State's Hoops 4 Hope. The circus is in town. And Olympic-level table tennis stops in Cary. Here's what's happening this weekend.
- What's on Tap
Charity events planned around Hoops 4 HopeThe Hillsborough Street Community Service Corporation is sponsoring Play 4Kay events on Hillsborough Street starting Feb. 8 to support Hoops 4 Hope and the Kay Yow Cancer Fund.
- WRAL SmartShopper
Love for Less: frugal Valentine's Day tipsShowering your loved ones with goodies is always fun to do on Valentine's Day, but not if it leaves you drowning in debt! With a little planning and creativity, you can show your loved ones you care and stay within your budget.
Other Recent Blogposts
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: Space travel has own traditions and supersitions
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: What happened to Pluto
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: The winter so far at RDU
- Brian Shrader's Siteseeing Blog: What's trending: Antelope shoes and ping-pong baby
- Brian Shrader's Siteseeing Blog: How cereal box designs have changed
2012 Honda Civic Sign and Drive $199 per month.
New Townhomes in Chapel Hill - promo price






WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.
This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.